Page 239 - Flipping book The Adam Paradox Hypothesis - Second Edition.pdf

The Ādam Paradox Hypothesis 216
Where Gradualism Cracks
Yet the closer we look, the more the slope fails to fit the evidence.
1. The Long Silence
By 315,000 years ago, humans already had modern anatomy. Their faces and
skulls could pass in a crowd today. But for nearly 200,000 years, there are no
durable symbols. No stable art, no permanent rituals, no cumulative traditions.
If cognition followed anatomy gradually, we should see a steady trail of
engravings, ornaments, or ritual markers from 300kya onward. Instead, the
record is flat — like a line that refuses to climb.
Archaeologists like d’Errico and Banks (2013) have modeled artifact frequencies
using Bayesian statistics. Their conclusion: the pattern overwhelmingly favors a
punctuated ignition over a slow slope. The chance of such long silence followed
by sudden abundance under gradualism is less than 1%.
2. The Sudden Symphony
Between 80,000 and 60,000 years ago, the silence breaks — and symbols erupt:
At Blombos Cave (South Africa,
~77kya), pieces of ochre engraved with
cross-hatched patterns.
Nassarius shell beads in North Africa and the Levant (~75kya), stained
with ochre, used as ornaments.
Diepkloof Rock Shelter (South Africa,
~60kya), ostrich eggshells engraved
with repeating motifs.
Qafzeh burials (Levant,
~70kya), skeletons interred with ochre, suggesting
ritual meaning.
This is not a gentle slope. It is a step-function: nothing, then everything.
To use plain math: a slope is like a hill rising steadily. A step-function is like a
staircase — flat for a long time, then suddenly vertical. Archaeology gives us a
staircase, not a hill.