Page 4 - Australian Defence Magazine September 2019
P. 4

Ethical technology – we can but should we?
KATHERINE ZIESING | CANBERRA
www.australiandefence.com.au
MANAGING EDITOR: Katherine Ziesing Email: katherineziesing@yaffa.com.au Tel: (02) 6203 9535 Mob: 0419 014 308.
DEPUTY EDITOR: Nigel Pittaway Email: cnpittaway@bigpond.com.au Tel 03 5428 7875
SENIOR CORRESPONDENT – SYDNEY: Julian Kerr Email: jhrhkerr@bigpond.net.au Tel: (02) 02 9960 4054 Mob: 0418 635 823
ONLINE EDITOR: Ewen Levick Email: ewenlevick@yaffa.com.au Tel (02) 9213 8249 Mob: 0447 961 544
CONTRIBUTORS THIS ISSUE Gregor Ferguson | Sydney Matt Rainbow | Adelaide James Gibson | Canberra
BRISBANE OFFICE
PO Box 9165, Wynnum Plaza, QLD 4178 AUSTRALIA
Tel: (07) 3348 6966 International: Tel: 61-7-3348 6966 Fax: 61-7-3348 6511
ASSOCIATE PUBLISHER: Kylie Leonard Email: kylieleonard@yaffa.com.au
BOOKS EDITOR: Peter Masters Email: petermasters@yaffa.com.au
NATIONAL ADVERTISING MANAGER: David Jones
Tel: (07) 3348 6966 Mob: 0412 188 100 Email: davidjones@yaffa.com.au
SUBSCRIPTIONS GREATMAGAZINES.COM.AU CALL 1800 807 760
EMAIL SUBSCRIPTIONS@YAFFA.COM.AU
LAST month, the Plan Jericho team in part- nership with DST Group and the Trusted Au- tonomous Systems CRC hosted a workshop on Ethical AI. With an aim “to derive and analyse ethical principles relevant to Defence contexts for AI and Autonomous systems that will in- form military leadership and ethics doctrine” the workshop brought together an interesting group of thinkers from a range of disciplines, both from Australia and overseas.
As the program notes, the rise of artificial in- telligence and autonomous systems provides an opportunity to make Defence operations more effective, but also presents unique ethical and le- gal challenges to decision-making, such as how to ensure appropriate action and moral respon- sibility for decisions. In essence, technology is the easy part; but should we?
“Ethics in the development and, more impor- tantly, in the deployment of new technologies is a challenge that must always be considered carefully,” Dr Tristan Perez, Leader Autonomy Assurance at the Trusted Autonomous Systems Defence CRC said to me. “This event provided a unique environment and opportunity to discuss these issues in relation to AI in defence contexts with world experts. The challenges faced by philosophers, ethicists, scientists, actuaries, law- yers, legislators, regulators, and developers are different in nature, and we saw elements of all these throughout the event.
“I wore my decision science hat to this event since my current work is not on the development of AI, but on the tools that will provide crucial information to stakeholders to inform their decision-making processes when it comes to au- tonomous systems and AI,” Dr Perez said. “My biggest take away learning was the importance that test & evaluation will play in creating de- fendable and robust decision processes for those who must make decisions about the use of AI.
“A colleague once described “Trust” as two el- ements; “Integrity” and “Competency.” The for- mer is to be incorporated as part of the design; thelatteraspartoftest&evaluation.”
And that is the key part of the AI conversa- tion, the issue of trust. Do we trust the algo- rithms making decisions? Can we defend how the decision was made? Who is accountable for the decisions that AI makes in the heat of battle
– the soldier that deployed the system or the de- veloper behind the code?
While it is easy to look at the platform side of the house when it comes to the application of AI (killer robots seems to be the common mental shortcut), there are so many parts of the Defence organisation that would benefit from the use of ethically applied AI.
The event format was split between traditional lectures and group workshops where issues were explored. During one such session, a group I was part of looked at the role of AI in logistics, health and sustainment; not the sexiest part of the De- fence landscape but vital ones nonetheless.
AI and big data are already being utilised in sustainment efforts. Vehicle, aircraft and ship borne Health and Usage Monitoring System (HUMS) have the ability to alert users and main- tainers about issues that need to be addressed. Logistics tracking systems have been in use for many years, with varying levels of effectiveness. The issues here are relatively well understood.
Issues on the health front, however, are murk- ier. Would AI decide that an ADF member who has fallen pregnant be sent home from deploy- ment without question; who in their chain of command should be told and when? Or what happens when an AI program decides who gets a medevac from the battlefield based on biometri- cally monitored soldier system with data linked to a medevac drone? Is the ADF comfortable with a computer potentially deciding who lives and dies? Where is the human in the loop? Can these rules be overruled or outright broken? None of these are easy questions and answers are variable depending on who you talk to and the individual circumstances of the situation.
The Trusted Autonomous Systems CRC is ac- tively working this very puzzle with Dr Perez and his team designing testing processes for systems to demonstrate what trust looks like. DST has also been working in this space for some time. Dr Rob Hunjet of DST spoke at the release of the STEM strategy last month and outlined this hypothetical. Whohasadriver’slicence?Haveyoueverhadatraf- fic infringement for parking or speeding? Ever been in a car accident? And you still have your licence? You wouldn’t if you were an unmanned vehicle.
It is important to keep having these hard ethical conversations as technology evolves.
Australia New Zealand Asia
Rest Of World
Via air mail 1 Year
1 Year
1 Year
1 Year
$A165.00 $A185.00 $A220.00 $A280.00
MAIL SUBSCRIPTIONS TO Subscription Department, Australian Defence Magazine GPO Box 606 Sydney NSW 2001 10% discount for subscription agents
MANAGING DIRECTOR: Tracy Yaffa PRODUCTION DIRECTOR: Matthew Gunn ART DIRECTOR: Ana Heraud STUDIO MANAGER: Lauren Esdaile DESIGNER: Maria Alegro MARKETING MANAGER: Lucy Yaffa
ADVERTISING PRODUCTION: John Viskovich Tel: (02) 9213 8215
Email: johnviskovich@yaffa.com.au
AUSTRALIAN DEFENCE MAGAZINE (ADM) is published in the second week of each month by Yaffa Media Pty Ltd
ACN 002 699 354.
17-21 Bellevue Street Surry Hills NSW 2010, Tel: (02) 9281 2333 Fax: (02) 9281 2750
Australian Defence Magazine also publishes the weekly newsletter Defence Week Premium and the Directory of Defence Suppliers
every six months.
Copyright ©2019
All material appearing in ADM is copyright. Reproduction inwholeorinpartisnotpermittedwithoutpermission in writing from the publisher. The publishers accept sole responsibility for the contents of this publication, which may in no way be taken to represent the views of the Department of Defence, the Australian Defence Force or any other agency of the Commonwealth of Australia.
4 | September 2019 | www.australiandefence.com.au
EDITORIAL


































































































   2   3   4   5   6