Page 2 - ArgumentativeGraphicOrganizer_Neat
P. 2

Shame


           Reason  2         School discrimination caused by teachers. Gregory tried to find different ways to succeed at school.

                Supporting Evidence                    Supporting Evidence                   Supporting Evidence
        “The teacher thought I was stupid.   “The teacher thought I was a         "I stood up and raised my hand. "What is
     Couldn't spell, couldn't read, and couldn’t  troublemaker. All she saw from the   it now?" "You forgot me?" She turned
     do arithmetic. Just stupid. Teachers were   front of the room was a little black boy   toward the blackboard. "I don't have time
      never interested in finding out that you   who squirmed in his idiot's seat and   to be playing with you, Richard."
     couldn't concentrate because you were so  made noises and poked the kids around   "My daddy said he'd..." "Sit down,
        hungry, because you hadn't had any   him. I guess she couldn't see a kid who   Richard, you're disturbing the class." "My
     breakfast. All you could think about was   made noises because he wanted     daddy said he'd give...fifteen dollars." She
      noontime; would it ever come? Maybe   someone to know he was there.”        turned around and looked mad. "We are
      you could sneak into the cloakroom and   (Gregory)                          collecting this money for you and your
      steal a bite of some kid's lunch out of a                                   kind, Richard Gregory. If your daddy can
             coat pocket.” (Gregory)                                              give fifteen dollars you have no business
                                                                                  being on relief."
                                                                                  "I got it right now, I got it right now, my
                                                                                  Daddy gave it to me to turn in today, my
                                                                                  daddy said." "And furthermore," she said,
                                                                                  looking right at me, her nostrils get big 2
                                                                                  and her lips getting thin and her eyes
                                                                                  opening wide, "We know you don't have a
                                                                                  daddy." Helene Tucker turned around, her
                                                                                  eyes full of tears. She felt sorry for me.
                                                                                  Then I couldn't see her too well because I
                                                                                  was crying, too.” (Gregory)


                   Commentary                            Commentary                             Commentary

    The teacher thought that Gregory was    Gregory just wanted to catch his      The teacher mistreated Gregory because
    a really stupid guy, because he was not  teacher’s attention in order to be   his lack of attention. She thought he was
    like the other guys. He was dumb, a     taken into account as the other       stupid and she wanted him to be quiet and
    hardheaded, in few words. But she       students. As I have said before,      polite in class. In order to make him feel
    never realized that he probably could   people tend to criticize others       ashamed, she remembers him he has no
                                                                                  father. That’s a real thing that really
    have problems that couldn’t allow him  without knowing what’s going on        happens when someone that hates you
    to concentrate in his studies. People   their lives. A good teacher should be   tries to make you feel miserable.
    tend to criticize others without        a perfect mate for his/her student,
    knowing what’s going on their lives. A  because a teacher spends most of the
    good teacher should be a perfect mate   time with his students and
    for his/her student, because a teacher   understand every single problem his/
    spends most of the time with his        her student could have. We students
    students.                               trust in teachers.








                                                                                 Level 2 - Argumentative Essay Graphic Organizer
   1   2   3   4   5   6   7