Page 48 - Critical Tasks in Law Enforcement 2020-2021 Sessioin

Task: Arrest in Retaliation for Exercise of First Amendment

Rights

Nieves v. Bartlett, 139 S.Ct. 1715 (2019).

• Generally, in the case of an arrest by an officer, probable cause will

defeat a plaintiff’s allegation that the officer’s arrest was in
retaliation for the exercise of the subject’s First Amendment rights

UNLESS:

• Plaintiff can show that officers generally exercise their discretion

and do not arrest for this crime but arrested in the subject’s case

because of the protected speech.

• Discovery will review data related to other arrests for the particular

offense.

©2021 Jack Ryan Legal & Liability Risk Management Institute 47