Page 216 - مجلة الملكية الفكرية العدد كامل
P. 216

‫العدد الثالث‬- ‫مجلة ثقافة الملكية الفكرية‬

interfered with the normal       violated Article 2 of the An-
business operation of Em-        ti-Unfair Competition Law,
erson. In addition, the court    and constituted unfair com-
also considered the fact         petition.
that Xiamen Anjier, Xiamen
HNBC and Wang Yiping,             India:
their legal representative
and person in charge, had         India, in its Trademarks Act,
filed to register trademarks     has provided for the protec-
identical or similar with more   tion of foreign trademarks
than 100 trademarks that         concerning the “Trans-bor-
were identical or similar to     der Reputation” principle.
famous brands in China,
such as Dow, Daimler, Uni-        Dongre v. Whirlpool Cor-
lever, etc.                      poration41: Plaintiff used to
                                 distribute products to US
 Based on the above facts,       Embassy in India exclusive-
the first-instance court holds   ly, but after some time they
that the two defendants’         entered into a partnership
piracy of the In-Sink-Er-        with TVS, and subsequently
ator Trademarks violated         the mark registered to them
the principle of good faith,     was abandoned by them and
disrupted the order of fair      hence was registered by the
market competition, dam-         defendant. This registration
aged the legitimate rights       was opposed by TVS Whirl-
and interests of the plaintiff,
                                 41 N.R. Dongre and ORS. V Whirl-

                                 pool Co. and ANR., HON’BLE Su-
                                 preme Court of India, (1996) 5 SCC
                                 714, 30th August 1996.

                                                                     216
   211   212   213   214   215   216   217   218   219   220   221