Page 90 - EducationWorld January 2023
P. 90

Books


         future and how it im-    ignore it for in Kumar’s
         pinges on her education   words, “that education    ECONOMIST GANDHI: THE
         — desire to be educated   which allows us to stay   ROOTS & THE RELEVANCE OF
         coupled with the deter-  indifferent to violence and   THE POLITICAL ECONOMY OF
         mination to pursue it.   war is no education at all”.   THE MAHATMA
         He cites examples from   On the contrary, peace and   Jaithirth Rao
         outside and inside school   non-violence should be   PENGUIN PORTFOLIO
         classrooms to explain    core components of school   Rs.599              Pages 256
         the tragic implications of   curriculums for children
         gendering that a young   to understand and engage
         girl faces. Such examples   with it critically.
         are peppered throughout    Indeed, no debate, no
         the text. Some of them are   conflict in education is too   story is an alluring and    The centrepiece of
         noteworthy and stand out   insignificant to escape the   rare tale of the triumph of   the book is a radical
         for the social harshness   attention of Prof. Kumar’s   human will over seemingly   re-evaluation of
         they portray. Incidents   critical lens. These short   insurmountable odds.   the crucial concept
         related to a headmistress   illuminating analyses   It reminds one of Albert   of trusteeship,
         refusing admission to girl   examine the deep fissures   Einstein’s famous tribute   which according to
         students because they are   inherent in Indian educa-  to Gandhi: “Generations to   Rao contests the
         child brides, and of four   tion and society — the   come, it may well be, will   conventional view
         adolescent girls jumping   death of Gandhi’s Basic   scarce believe that such   that Gandhi was
         into a well because they   Education, the duality of   a man as this one ever in   opposed to capitalism
         had been scolded by their   Nehru’s India, urban-rural   flesh and blood walked
         teacher for poor academic   polarity, Kerala’s progress   upon this Earth.”
         performance. These inci-  in literacy but its lack of   One might even suggest   of the world and whatever
         dents are deeply evocative   pedagogic modernism, are   that Gandhi’s life was   could have remained hid-
         of the bleak reality of be-  adroitly brought out.  an allegory, his death a   den, he revealed it himself
         ing caste/cast as a woman   Smaller Citizens: Writ-  metaphor, and his afterlife   by way of his letters,
         in the Indian context.   ings on the Making of   an unsettled debate. Argu-  speeches, and voluminous
           The author also turns   Indian Citizens is a clarion   ably, no other person in   writings, including private
         his attention to peace and   call for all engaged with   recent memory has been   correspondence, that he
         the need for children to   education and welfare of   so minutely evaluated   left behind for poster-
         experience it in their daily   the child. Let’s take charge   as Gandhi. As a result,   ity in almost a hundred
         lives at school. Since the   of changing the direction   Gandhi has become, in   volumes.
         early 20th century, peace   and content of education.  large measure, a subject of   The fact that Gandhi
         education programmes          VEENA KAPOOR (The   hermeneutical delight; an   continues to evince abid-
         around the world have              Book Review)  open book, lending him-  ing interest is also in part
         represented a spectrum of                        self to ready investigation   because he — in his life,
         themes, including nucle-  Trusteeship            and exegesis. Each aspect   thought and action — be-
         arism, environmental                             of his life is closely exam-  came a curious synthesis
         responsibility, interna-                         ined, each word weighed   of disparate tendencies
         tional understanding,    philosophy              with care, every action   that were ascendant in
         non-violence, conflict                           measured with precision,   India during the 20th cen-
         resolution, democracy,   revisited               every secret is rummaged   tury. Tagore’s humanism,
         tolerance of diversity                           through with diligence,   Ambedkar’s egalitarian-
         and coexistence.  In the        AHATMA           and even his silences are   ism, Nehru’s materialism
         context of India’s freedom      Gandhi is pos-   sought to be interpreted   and Savarkar’s Hindutva,
         struggle, its psychological  Msibly the greatest   by authors, commentators,   are all subsumed in Gan-
         dimensions and Gandhi’s   and most remembered    critics and admirers alike.   dhi’s eclectic world view
         interpretation of it, peace   Indian to have lived since   This is in part because   by a somewhat Hegelian-
         education acquires a wider   Buddha. His greatness,   — unlike many of his con-  esque dialectic. This
         and deeper connotation.   however, was not in his in-  temporaries — Gandhi did   explains why Gandhi has
           Schools and colleges   vulnerability — but in his   not distinguish between   so successfully endeared
         socialise the young to   struggle to overcome his   the private and public. He   himself to all political ide-
         either fear the world or   many frailties. Gandhi’s   led his life under the glare   ologies as there is some-

         90    EDUCATIONWORLD   JANUARY 2023
   85   86   87   88   89   90   91   92   93   94