Page 69 - EW July 2022
P. 69

Books




             Piketty's latest            A BRIEF HISTORY OF EQUALITY                   sectors that have become
                                                                                       privatised including educa-
             oeuvre                      Thomas Piketty                                tion, health, transport and

                                         Harvard University Press                      energy.
                                         Rs.799                                           Although Piketty
                   ROFESSOR OF                                                         favours much higher
                   economics at the      Pages 244                                     income-tax rates, policies
             PSchool for Ad-                                                           that redistribute prop-
             vanced Studies in the So-                                                 erty rather than income
             cial Sciences and associate                                               are at the heart of his
             chair at the Paris School   shaped by self-interest.   Economist Thomas   programme. This agenda
             of Economics, Thomas     The book argued that un-  Piketty summarises     includes reparations for
             Piketty attained global   less capitalism is reformed,   his previous works   descendants of enslaved
             fame with his best-selling   democracies worldwide   to make his research   and colonised people and
             Capital in the Twenty-   will flounder.            accessible to a wider   encouraging countries in
             First Century (2013),      The above two books     audience               the global south to tax the
             which highlighted wealth   were voluminous in size                        fortunes of non-residents
             and income inequality in   and encyclopaedic in   is now at least middle   who do business there.
             Europe and the US since   scope. In contrast, the   class, whereas before the   Cancellation of debts
             the 18th century.        book under review is a   20th century there was no   and a programme he calls
                The book argued that   pithy 244 pages presented   middle class to speak of.   “inheritance for all,” in
             the rate of capital return in   in ten chapters in which   The right to vote, formerly   which wealth taxes will
             developed countries is per-  Piketty summarises his   restricted even in democ-  reduce large fortunes and
             sistently greater than the   previous works, Capital in   racies to male property   provide everyone with a fi-
             rate of economic growth,   the Twenty-First Century   owners, was well on its way   nancial cushion, is also on
             and that this would cause   and Capital and Ideol-  to becoming universal.  his prescription. He also
             wealth inequality to     ogy to make his research   What prompted this    wants to transfer a large
             increase in the future. Pik-  more accessible to a wider   progress? Piketty has a   measure of control over
             etty proposed improving   audience not necessarily   straightforward answer:   corporations from their
             education systems arguing   economists.           the advent of progres-  managers and sharehold-
             that diffusion of knowl-   Much of the current    sive taxes on income and   ers in favour of employees,
             edge, skills, and ideas of   discussion on inequality   wealth, and rise of the com-  and create “a system of
             productivity would act as   focuses on the period since   prehensive welfare state.   egalitarian funding for
             main mechanisms to lower   1980, when the benefits   Taxes reduced inequality   political campaigns, the
             inequality.              of growth began to accrue   and paid for the welfare   media and think tanks”.
                In 2019, his next book   more narrowly to the rich   state, which provided edu-  All this would result in “a
             Capital and Ideology also   than before. While discuss-  cation, healthcare, old-age   profound transformation
             became a bestseller. It   ing this phenomenon,    pensions and protection   of the world economic
             broadened Piketty’s earlier   Piketty acknowledges   against severe deprivation.  system”.
             scope by focusing on the   that there was an earlier   In Capital, Piketty   What do Piketty’s
             sociology of inequality,   optimistic narrative of   advocated a “global tax   prescriptions look like
             experienced in various   the world’s astounding   on wealth” as a possible   when viewed through the
             societies in history. The   progress toward equality   remedy for inequality. In A   lens of a partially develop-
             book’s central thesis was   during the 19th century.  Brief History, he develops   ing economy like India?
             that inequality is not an ac-  Life expectancy rose   the concept of a progres-  His primary field of study
             cident but rather a feature   from 26 to 72 years and,   sive increase in taxes on   was France, then Europe,
             of capitalism that can be   with the spread of com-  the wealthy. Piketty calls   then USA and rest of the
             reversed only through state   pulsory state-provided   upon the State to increase   developed ‘West’.  French
             intervention. It argued   education, literacy rate   access to quality health-  annual per capita income
             that throughout history,   grew from 10 to 85 per-  care, education, employ-  is above US $40,000 while
             elites have tried to justify   cent. Slavery and colonial-  ment through the progres-  in the US, it is $60,000.
             inequality by claiming it is   ism, once endemic, were   sive implementation of   On the other hand,
             natural and that the status   substantially abolished.   taxation on the wealthiest.   India’s per capita income
             quo brings stability, but   Perhaps half the popula-  He also advocates “decom-  is about $2,000, i.e, 5
             these are biased excuses,   tion of the developed world   modification” of certain   percent of the West. We

             68    EDUCATIONWORLD   JULY 2022
   64   65   66   67   68   69   70   71   72   73   74