Page 98 - Demo

Îöåíêà ãîñòèíèö ñðàâíèòåëüíûì ïîäõîäîì
Äìèòðèé Íîâîæèëîâ,
çàìåñòèòåëü ãåíåðàëüíîãî äèðåêòîðà
ÎÎÎ «Öåíòð îöåíêè ñîáñòâåííîñòè»,
ïðàêòèêóþùèé îöåíùèê,
÷ëåí ðàáî÷åãî îðãàíà Ñîâåòà ïî ìåòîäè÷åñêîìó îáåñïå÷åíèþ è ýêñïåðòèçå ïðè Ñîâåòå ïî îöåíî÷íîé äåÿòåëüíîñòè Ìèíýêîíîìðàçâèòèÿ Ðîññèè
Âûäåðæêà èç Ðàáîòû Äìèòðèÿ Íîâîæèëîâà «Íåêîòîðûå âîïðîñû îöåíêè ãîñòèíè÷íîé íåäâèæèìîñòè» (2017 ã.)
Ïðåäñòàâëåííûé ìàòåðèàë ïîñâÿùåí àíàëèçó âîçìîæíîñòè ïðèìåíåíèÿ ñðàâíèòåëüíîãî ïîäõîäà ïðèìåíèòåëüíî ê ãîñòèíè÷íîé íåäâèæèìîñòè. Ïðèâåäåíû äàííûå èç çàðóáåæíûõ èñòî÷íèêîâ, ïîñâÿùåííûå ðàçëè÷íûì àñïåêòàì îöåíêè îòåëåé, è ïðîàíàëèçèðîâàíà âîçìîæíîñòü èõ ïðèìåíåíèÿ â ðîññèéñêîé îöåíî÷íîé äåÿòåëüíîñòè.
Ïðè÷èíû íàïèñàíèÿ Ðàáîòû «Íåêîòîðûå âîïðîñû îöåíêè ãîñòèíè÷íîé íåäâèæèìîñòè»
b C!%це““е %це...*, , де"ел%Cме...2= г%“2,...,ч.../. %KAе*2%" " p%““,, , ƒ= !3Kе›%м "/ “...,л%“ь “лед3ю?ее:
 b “3?е“2"3ю?,. 3чеK...,*=. C% %це...*е ...ед%“2=2%ч...% ,ƒл%›е.../ %“%Kе......%“2, %це...*, д%.%д%C!,...%- “ ?,. =*2,"%", %“%Kе......% .2% *=“=е2“ г%“2,...,ч.../. %KAе*2%", %це...*= *%2%!/. " м,!%"%L C!=*2,*е "/дел е2“ " %2дель.../е ч=“2, 3чеK.../. *3!“%". o!, .2%м ƒ=ч=“23ю !%““,L“*,е ="2%!/ C!,"%д 2 ,...-%!м=ц,ю ,ƒ 3чеK...,*%" C% г%“2,...,ч...%м3 дел3, *%2%!= ...е “%ƒд=е2 ед,...%L *=!2,.../ де 2ель...%“-
2, %KAе*2%" !=ƒме?е..., .
 b% м...%›е“2"е “3?е“2"3ю?,. !%““,L“*,. 3чеK...,*%", C%“%K,L , м=2е!,=л%" C% г%“2,...,ч...%м3 дел3
...е “%де!›,2“ ,...-%!м=ц,, % де 2ель...%“2, г%“2,...,ц, *%2%!= C%ƒ"%л е2 C%“2!%,2ь .--е*2,"...3ю м%дель %це...*, г%“2,...,ц/. o!, .2%м !%““,L“*,е 3чеK.../е C%“%K, C% г%“2,...,ч...%м3 дел3 " %“...%"- ...%м “%де!›=2 м...%›е“2"% ,...-%!м=ц,,, *%2%!= *=“=е2“ м...%г,. “2%!%... де 2ель...%“2, *!%ме 2%L,
*%2%!= м%›е2 ƒ=,...2е!е“%"=2ь %це...?,*= $ %Cе!=ц,%......%L.
 a%льш,...“2"% ƒ=!3Kе›.../. C3Kл,*=ц,L *=“=ю2“ %2дель.../. =“Cе*2%" %C!еделе..., “2%,м%“2, %2елеL, C%д!=ƒ3ме"= , ч2% K=ƒ%"/е C%... 2, , “2!3*23!= %Cе!=ц,%......%L де 2ель...%“2, 3›е ,ƒ"е“2...= ч,2=2елю.
 o!, ƒ...=*%м“2"е “ %2че2=м, %K %це...*е г%“2,...,ц, "/C3?е....../м, !%““,L“*,м, %це...%ч.../м, *%мC=- ..., м,, м%›...% ƒ=ме2,2ь, ч2% %це...*= 2=*,. %KAе*2%" "/ƒ/"=е2 “л%›...%“2, C% ...е“*%ль*,м C!,ч,...=м.
 mе "“е ƒ=*=ƒч,*, %це...*, г%“2,...,ч.../. %KAе*2%" г%2%"/ C!ед%“2="л 2ь д=....../е % де 2ель...%“2,
%KAе*2%" %це...*,, = е“л, г%2%"/, 2% -%!м= C!ед%“2="ле..., 2!еK3е2 “Cец,=ль...%L %K!=K%2*,.
 mе "“егд= %це...?,*, ƒ=C!=ш,"=ю2 3 ƒ=*=ƒч,*%" , C!,"%д 2 " %2че2=. м=2е!,=л/, ...е%K.%д,м/е
дл %це...*,, = ,...%гд= ,“C%льƒ3ю2 д=....../е , м%дел,, *%2%!/е ...ед%“2=2%ч...% *%!!е*2...% %2!=›=ю2
%“%Kе......%“2, %KAе*2= %це...*,.
 )=“2% "%ƒ...,*=ю2 C!%Kлем/ “ ,“C%льƒ%"=...,ем %Kƒ%!%", C3Kл,*3ем/. =...=л,2,*=м,, ч2% C!%-
,“.%д,2 *=* " “" ƒ, “ ...ед%“2=2%ч...%“2ью 2=*,. м=2е!,=л%", 2=* , “ -%!м%L ,. C!ед“2="ле..., .
 mе*%2%!/е %це...%ч.../е *%мC=...,, " p%““,, C!%"%д 2 %це...*3 г%“2,...,ц, %C,!= “ь ...= ,...-%!м=ц,ю, &ïîëó÷åííóþ èç äàííûõ ñîáñòâåííûõ ïîäðàçäåëåíèé, êîòîðûå çàíèìàþòñÿ ïðîäàæåé è óïðàâ- ëåíèåì íåäâèæèìîñòüþ[. q2=2,“2,че“*,е д=....../е, *%2%!/е м%›...% C%л3ч,2ь " м=2е!,=л=. p%“- “2=2= , %2*!/2/. ,“2%ч...,*=., “%де!›=2 ,...-%!м=ц,ю %2!/"%ч...3ю , 2!еK3ю?3ю “3?е“2"е......%L
Cе!е!=K%2*, дл “%ƒд=..., !=K%ч,. м%делеL.
b =...=л,2,че“*,. м=2е!,=л=. C!ед“2="ле...,е ,...-%!м=ц,, 2=*›е ...е "“егд= C%м%г=е2 %це...?,*3, *%2%- !/L ...е ƒ...=*%м д%“2=2%ч...% де2=ль...% “ -3...*ц,%...,!%"=...,ем г%“2,...,ч...%г% *%мCле*“= 2=*, *=* ег% ",д,2 C!%-е““,%...=ль.../L г%“2,...,ч.../L м=!*е2%л%г ,л, ме...ед›е!, "ед3?,L 3че2 %Cе!=ц,%......%L де 2ель...%“2,.
l...%г,е C!%Kлем/ %це...*, г%“2,...,ц “" ƒ=.../ “ 2ем, ч2% K%льш,...“2"% *%мC=...,L, *%2%!/е C!%-е““,%- ...=ль...% ƒ=...,м=ю2“ %це...*%L г%“2,...,ц, ,мею2 &=ме!,*=...“*,е *%!...,[. n..., ,“C%льƒ3ю2 м%дел,, C%“2!%- е....../е ...= K3.г=л2е!“*%м 3че2е USALI1 (“2=...д=!2 US GAAP2). m= ...еL ›е %“...%"=.../ д=....../е “2=2,“2,*, , =...=л,2,*,, *%2%!3ю C3Kл,*3ю2 “Cец,=л,ƒ,!%"=....../е %!г=...,ƒ=ц,, ƒ= !3Kе›%м, , *%2%!3ю ,“C%льƒ3ю2 г%- “2,...,ч.../е %Cе!=2%!/ , *%...“3ль2=...2/ C% "“ем3 м,!3.
1 Uniform System of Accounts for the Lodging Industry (Åäèíàÿ ñèñòåìà ó÷åòà äëÿ ãîñòèíè÷íîé èíäóñòðèè). 2 ×àñòè÷íî òàêîé ó÷åò ìîæåò áûòü ïîñòðîåí è â ÌÑÔÎ, íî ïðàêòè÷åñêè íåâîçìîæåí â ðàìêàõ ÐÑÁÓ.
1266 • l`i• 2017 98 a~kkeŠem| • RWAY
Ýêîíîìèêà íåäâèæèìîñòè. Îöåíêà