Page 6 - ARUBA TODAY
P. 6

A6   U.S. NEWS
                       Friday 18 May 2018


















            Homeless jailed frequently under 'habitual drunkard' law



                                                                                                   By DENISE LAVOIE             same  law  and  set  him  on
                                                                                                   RICHMOND, Va. (AP) — For  the same path at a young
                                                                                                   the  past  six  years,  Richard  age, when he would often
                                                                                                   Walls has been in jail more  put moonshine in his baby
                                                                                                   often than not. The longest  bottle.
                                                                                                   stretch  of  time  he's  spent  "They  put  me  in  this  jail  to
                                                                                                   outside a cell is 30 days.   harass me," he said in a re-
                                                                                                   Walls  is  not  a  hardened  cent interview at the Rich-
                                                                                                   criminal,  but  he  is  what  mond  City  Justice  Center,
                                                                                                   Virginia  calls  a  "habitual  where  he's  been  jailed  for
                                                                                                   drunkard,"  a  designation  the past three months.
                                                                                                   that allows police to arrest  "I never hurt anyone in my
                                                                                                   him and jail him for up to a  life or committed a felony,"
                                                                                                   year if he's caught with al-  he said.
                                                                                                   cohol.                       Opponents say the law tar-
                                                                                                   The law, which dates back  gets  homeless  alcoholics
                                                                                                   to the 1930s, is being chal-  who have nowhere else to
                                                                                                   lenged  by  the  Legal  Aid  drink but in public. People
                                                                                                   Justice Center, a nonprofit  without the habitual-drunk-
                                                                                                   advocacy group that pro-     ard  designation  can  also
                                                                                                   vides legal services to low-  be  arrested  for  public  in-
                                                                                                   income people. The group  toxication,  but  they  don't
                                                                                                   accuses  state  prosecutors  face any jail time.
                                                                                                   of using it to punish home-  From  2007  to  2015,  more
                                                                                                   less alcoholics. A judge dis-  than  1,220  people  were
            In this Tuesday, May 1, 2018 photo, attorney Mary Frances Charlton, left, talks with inmate Richard
            Walls during an interview at the Richmond City Jail in Richmond, Va.                   missed the lawsuit last year,  designated  as  "habitual
                                                                                                   but  the  group  appealed.  drunkards"  in  Virginia,  ac-
                                                                                                   The  4th  U.S.  Circuit  Court  cording  to  data  reported
                                                                                                   of Appeals is weighing the  to the Virginia Department
                                                                                                   case.                        of   Alcoholic   Beverage
                                                                                                   Virginia  and  Utah  are  the  Control.
                                                                                                   only  two  states  with  so-  The  lawsuit  alleges  that
                                                                                                   called  interdiction  laws  the law criminalizes addic-
                                                                                                   that  make  it  a  crime  for  tion  and  violates  the  8th
                                                                                                   people  designated  as  ha-  Amendment       prohibition
                                                                                                   bitual drunkards to possess,  against  cruel  and  unusual
                                                                                                   consume  or  purchase  al-   punishment. It also says the
                                                                                                   cohol,  or  even  attempt  to  law  violates  due-process
                                                                                                   do so, according to a sur-   rights  because  the  cases
                                                                                                   vey of state laws done by  are  brought  in  civil  court
                                                                                                   the legal aid center.        and  the  defendants  are
                                                                                                   Under the law, prosecutors  not  guaranteed  a  lawyer
                                                                                                   can  go  to  court  to  ask  a  as they are in criminal cas-
                                                                                                   judge to declare someone  es.
                                                                                                   a habitual drunkard. Once  "This  criminalizes  the  status
                                                                                                   that  happens,  police  can  of being a homeless alco-
                                                                                                   arrest that person for being  holic,"  said  Mary  Frances
                                                                                                   publicly  intoxicated,  pos-  Charlton, the lead attorney
                                                                                                   sessing alcohol, being near  challenging the law.
                                                                                                   open containers of alcohol  The  law  gives  prosecutors
                                                                                                   or even smelling of alcohol.  discretion  on  when  they
                                                                                                   In addition to jail time, they  can  go  to  court  and  seek
                                                                                                   face fines of up to $2,500.  the  "habitual  drunkard"
                                                                                                   Walls, 48, has been locked  designation.  It  doesn't  re-
                                                                                                   up at least 30 times for al-  quire a specific number of
                                                                                                   cohol   possession   since  alcohol-related offenses.
                                                                                                   being  given  the  "habitual  "Our  officers  would  much
                                                                                                   drunkard"  designation  in  rather do other things than
                                                                                                   2012.  He  says  his  father  this," he said. "We hate see-
                                                                                                   was  an  alcoholic  who  ing  people  destroy  their
                                                                                                   was prosecuted under the  own lives."q
   1   2   3   4   5   6   7   8   9   10   11