Page 73 - BOGmanual_2024October

Case: 09-30925 Document: 00511366200 Page: 8 Date Filed: 01/31/2011

deceive” the public. See In re R.M.J., 455 U.S. at 202. A depiction of a scene or
4
picture can be presented in a non-deceptive way in an attorney advertisement.
See Zauderer, 471 U.S. at 647. The portrayal of a judge in an advertisement

may also be presented in a way that is not deceptive. See Alexander v. Cahill,

598 F.3d 79, 92S95 (2d Cir. 2010), cert. denied, 79 U.S.L.W. 3102 (2010)

(reviewing advertisement that “depicted a judge in the courtroom and stated

that the judge is there to make sure [the trial] is fair”) (quotations omitted)

(alteration in original). Further, and as the district court determined, it is

possible for an attorney to present past results in a manner that is not

misleading. Public Citizen, 642 F. Supp. 2d at 553. Finally, it is similarly

obvious that a nickname or motto that might imply an ability to obtain results

can be employed in a non-deceptive fashion.
Because these five challenged rules all target speech that is only

potentially misleading, the First Amendment is implicated. The court must

review these Louisiana Rules under Central Hudson or Zauderer. In accordance

with these cases, we apply Central Hudson to the speech restrictions in Rules

7.2(c)(1)(D), (J), and (L) and Zauderer to the disclosure obligations set forth in

Rules 7.2(c)(1)(I) and (c)(10).

B. Applying Central Hudson to Advertising Restrictions

Under Central Hudson, a restriction on commercial speech survives First

Amendment scrutiny if: (1) “the asserted governmental interest is substantial,”

(2) the regulation “directly advances” that interest, and (3) the regulation “is not

more extensive than is necessary to serve that interest.” Thompson v. W. States
Med. Ctr., 535 U.S. 357, 367 (2002) (internal quotation omitted). This test is

4 Because we hold that at least one type of speech that triggers Rule 7.2(c)(10)’s
disclaimer formatting requirements is potentially misleading, we need not address whether
any other triggering speech is also potentially misleading.

8