Page 131 - Understanding Machine Learning

10.7 Exercises 113

Show that the error of h t w.r.t. the distribution D (t+1) is exactly 1/2. That is, show
that for every t ∈ [T ]
m
(t+1)
D 1 [y i =h t (x i )] = 1/2.
i
i=1
10.4 In this exercise we discuss the VC-dimension of classes of the form L(B,T). We
proved an upper bound of O(dT log(dT )), where d = VCdim(B). Here we wish to
prove an almost matching lower bound. However, that will not be the case for all
classes B.
1. Note that for every class B and every number T ≥ 1, VCdim(B) ≤
VCdim(L(B,T)). Find a class B for which VCdim(B) = VCdim(L(B,T)) for
every T ≥ 1.
Hint: Take X to be a finite set.
d
2. Let B d be the class of decision stumps over R . Prove that log(d) ≤
VCdim(B d ) ≤ 5+ 2log(d).
Hints:
For the upper bound, rely on Exercise 10.11.
k
For the lower bound, assume d = 2 .Let A be a k ×d matrix whose columns
k
are all the d binary vectors in {±1} . The rows of A form a set of k vectors
d
d
in R . Show that this set is shattered by decision stumps over R .
3. Let T ≥ 1 be any integer. Prove that VCdim(L(B d ,T )) ≥ 0.5T log(d).
Hint: Construct a set of T k instances by taking the rows of the matrix A from
2
T
the previous question, and the rows of the matrices 2A,3A,4A,..., A. Show
2
that the resulting set is shattered by L(B d ,T).
10.5 Efficiently Calculating the Viola and Jones Features Using an Integral Image: Let
A bea24 × 24 matrix representing an image. The integral image of A, denoted by

I(A), is the matrix B such that B i, j = i ≤i, j ≤ j A i, j .
Show that I(A) can be calculated from A in time linear in the size of A.
Show how every Viola and Jones feature can be calculated from I(A) in a con-
stant amount of time (that is, the runtime does not depend on the size of the
rectangle defining the feature).