Page 148 - INDONESIA ISLAMIC CULTURE
P. 148

the coastal regions that created certain    unity. The Islamization of  Patani,  Bugis-  Spain imagined that if it could defeat the   or the clergy, to maintain the integrity
 traditions, supported by markets and   Makassar, Sulu-Maguindanao and so   Ternate-Sulu coalition, not only these two   of each tradition. So, the traditions
 boarding schools pesantren, had to find   on show how each felt to be part of the   areas that would be under its control but   in their respective territories served
 other ways to preserve their perspective   larger cultural world. No matter how the   Kalimantan and Java as well.  as the mythical foundations of their
 on cosmopolitan culture, if not their direct   Islamization of Banjarmasin, Lampung   In the 18th century, the atmosphere   behavioral patterns. At the rational level,
 trading relations. As the owners of the   and Palembang went, it was not isolated   of unity offered the possibility for the   traditions emerged that could be used
 legacy of the Wali Songo ---the saints   from Mataram’s political domination.   emergence of calls for para-Islamist-  as yardsticks to determine what was
 who originated from the north-coast--- the   Subsequent developments showed   inspirited jihad both in Java and in the   reasonable and what not.
 north coast cities, especially Cirebon,   that they were part of the Malay Islamic   Straits of Malacca. It also offered the
 developed works on Islamic mysticism. In   intellectual tradition. In fact, if the 17th   opportunity for a “political adventurer”   The declining power of the kings as the
                                                 rulers in possession of the monopoly
 the central court in the hinterland, literary   century was marked by Aceh’s leading   to call for holy war in the Straits of
 works and pre-Islamic philosophy were   role in the development of intellectual   Malacca and in the Sunda Strait under   in taking initiatives because of the
 re-used as the sources of in new cultural   traditions, at the end of the 18th century   his direction. He wanted to build a   penetration of Western colonialism
 ways of thinking.  But political dominance   it was Palembang’s turn to be given this   palace founded on jihad against the   (the 18th century in Java and the
 48
 49
 was already the hands of the VOC.   honor.  Like Aceh, which has its own   unbelievers. 50  19th century in other cultural-political
 As a result, this development not only   language, Palembang also produced   areas), meant the loss of one of the
 sharpened the differences in the maritime   texts in the Malay language.  The relationships between kingdoms   tradition’s supporting institutionalizations.
 and agricultural state systems, as Van   Dynastic relations and religious unity   or political entities that sometimes   Meanwhile, modern bureaucratic
 Leur said, or turned coastal life into a   as well as shared political interests are   showed their efforts to give meaning to   systems and new styles of economic
 distinctive north-coastal cultural pattern,   various elements that can join various   the concept of cultural unity in political   exploitation potentially threatened the
 but also strengthened the development   areas into a political unity in a joint effort   behavior were frequently marred by   sustainability of both types of traditions.
 towards the tradition of dialogue.  against the penetration of economic   conflicts. The triangle dispute between   But, perhaps it is not a historical irony
          Johor, Jambi and Palembang (17th
                                                 that these traditions evolved into the
 The conceptualization of these two   monopolism and Western expansion. In   century), for example, cannot be   bases of cultural identity on the one
 traditions is necessary as an analytical   this regard, for example, the initial phase   explained by the two concepts of tradition   hand and as the new foundations for
 tool to understand the dynamics of Islam   of the perpetual war between the Moros   introduced above. Both traditions   political conservatism, on the other.
 in each political region. Meanwhile,   and Spain was characterized by the   ---the tradition of integration and that   The mythologizing process that had
 inter-state or regional inter-political   involvement of Brunei and subsequently   of dialogue--- can only explain internal   taken place and was promoted by the
 relationships and various historical   Ternate. At that time too (the 16th century)   conditions. It is in the interest of groups   literati, clerical or not, and the continuing
 events had turned Southeast Asia into   49.  See for example G.WJ. Drewes, Direction for   in power, whether the Sultan and his   validity of the structure of plausibility,
                                                                                  51
 a region bound by a shared sense of   Travelers on the Mystic Path: Zakariyya al-Ansari’s   court officials and local authorities,
 Kitab Path al Rahman and its Indonesian Version.   51.  On this concept see Peter L. Berger &Thomas
 48.  Theodore G.Th. Pigeaud, Literature of Java,   With an Appendix on Palembang Manuscripts and   50.  J. Kathirithamby-Wells, “Ahmad Shah Ibn   Luckmann, The Social Construction of Reality: A
 Vol. 1: Synopsis of Javanese Literature, The   Authors. The Hague: Martinus Nijhoff, (KITLV-  Iskandar and the Late 17th Century Holy War in   Treatise in the Sociology of Knowledge, New York:
 Hague: Martinus Nijhoff, 1967.  Verhandelingen 81), 1977.  Indonesia”, JMBRAS XUI, 1, 1970, pp. 48-63.  Doubleday 7 Company, 1966.



 138  Indonesian Islamic Culture in Historical Perspectives     Indonesian Islamic Culture in Historical Perspectives  139
   143   144   145   146   147   148   149   150   151   152   153