Page 38 - 1 to 18 August 2020
P. 38

Imphal Times Supplementary issue                                                          Page No. 2
                                              ADDRESSING THE ZELIANGRONG QUESTION

                                              By - Pakinrichapbo,  Advocate  (1915 -1993). In Nagaland context,  Zeliangrong  community  still  from GoI and NNPGs solution for
                                               Samziuram Village, Peren  fellow  Naga  tribes often question  believes  in  the  Naga  cause  and  the Nagas.
              Negative remarks on            The Naga peace talk is on the edge  Zeliangrong existence in Nagaland  continues  to  support  the  Naga  With  GoI  and  NSCN  IM,  the
                                                   Nagaland
                                                                                                  situation  is  not  better,  may  be
                                                                                 cause carry forward by NSCN and
                                                               without  bothering  to  find  out  its
                                                                                 thus suspended their movement for
                                                               historical  backgrounds.  Late
                                                                                                  even  worse.  The  NSCN-IM  has
                positive activities          of  conclusion  as  reported  in  the  Gaidinliu though born and raised in  homeland. The Zeliangrong people  said  they  have  not  given  up  on
                                                               Longkao Village, under Tamenglong
                                                                                 especially  living  in Assam  and
                                             Nagaland post dated 15.07.2020. It
                                                                                                  integration,  but  Interlocutor  had
            Is this a way to encourage       goes further to state that in a major  District  Manipur,  had  huge  Manipur still believe in  the results  time   and   again   maintain
                                                                                 of Naga Peace talks with the hope
                                                               followers from  her kindred tribes
                                                                                                  integration of Naga areas is out of
                                             breakthrough Government of India
                                             Representative and Interlocutor, Mr.
                                                                                 of integration.
                                                               living  in  several  villages  under
                                                                                                  the  picture. How  can  Nagas  get
              COVID-19 warriors?             Ravi,  and  also  Governor  of  Tening  Sub-division  (Peren)  and  Forlornly, the Naga movement had  separate  flag  and  constitution
                                                               also from Zeliangrong people living
                                             Nagaland  and  the  Working
                                                                                                  even  when  GoI  is  not  willing  to
                                                                                 come a long way crossing 70 years
                                             Committee  of  NNPGs  agreed  to  in  Dima  Hasao  formerly  North  now  and  counting,  in  these long  redraw state boundaries, which is
                  senior resident, who has been known for his dedication  finalize  draft agreement  for early  Cachar Hills, which is  one of the  years  Zeliangrongs faith  in  Naga  legally  permissible  within  the
                 to the cause for the fight against the COVID-19 pandemic,  settlement to the decades old Naga  main  reasons  why  Zeliangrong  cause remain as strong as it was in  constitution? From the time of the
              Awas seen collapsed, perhaps due exhaustion while on  Political  issue.  The  said  press  entity exists in Nagaland.  early NNC days, even overlooking  formation of NSCN  in  1980 and
           duty to save COVID-19 infected patients at  JNIMS.  The modus  statement also mentioned that both   Followers of Naga political history  the  reality  that  the  Naga  tribes  later split of NSCN to NSCN-IM
           operandi of how  health workers  have been assigned to provide all  the parties have chalked out action  will be aware of the fact that when  leading the movement now seems  and  NSCN-K  in  1988  to  2020
           available health care facilities at CCCs at both JNIMS and RIMS as  plan for impending final agreement,  Naga Movement gained momentum  to  have  different  aspirations  to  (which comes to total of 40 years
           well  as  others  have  been  known  and  this  newspaper  had  also  so  the  negotiation  is  closed  across all Naga villages from middle  achieve  from  the peace  talks, as  and  still  counting),  Zeliangrong
           highlighted few.                  between  Interlocutor  and WC  of  part of 1950s, Apeh Gaidinliu met  most  of  the  leading  tribes  lives  people  have  given  its  due  share
              Lately, a COVID-19 positive pregnant lady delivered a baby at  NNPGs as per the deadline of  the  Pandit Jawaharlal Nehru at Imphal  within  a  single  state  and  have  of  cooperation  to  IM,  so  what
           RIMS hospital under strict measures to ensure that no health workers  31 st  October 2019.  (in 1953 ) and made him conscious  nothing much to  lose  but to gain  more  one  could  anticipate  if  the
           in the team  got infected with the virus. There are many pregnant  However, the narrative on the other  of her people living conditions and  more after  the  final  agreement is  peace  talks  fail  to  integrate
           ladies in the hospital where gynecologists and nurses are keeping an  side is different  with  the GoI  and  also  to  do  something  spreading  executed.  While  for  the  naive  Zeliangrong  people  and  their
           eagle eye round the clock to make sure that those under health care  NSCN-IM  failing  to  break  the  across the three States. She soon  Zeliangrongs  their  faith  in  Naga  lands?  Or  one  expects  all
           services are safe and sound taking all risks during this pandemic.  impasse on the issue of co-existing  mobilized  members  of  the  cause  could  not  shake  them  out  Zeliangrongs to fully cooperate if
              A few days back Sky Hospital, a private run cardiac treatment  as  two  entities  and  share  Zeliangrong  who  believed in her  unless the contents  of impending  IM  decides  to  resume  their
           center in a press  statement said that their hospital is open  and not  sovereignty with IM still not giving  cause  to  fight  for  Zeliangrong  final agreement do the talking.  guerrilla warfare  against India  in
           included  in  the  containment  zone  announced  by  the  district  up  on  separate  flag,  constitution,  homeland  under  the  Indian  As an ardent believer in Naga unity,  case the peace talks break down.
           administration.  The press statement  indicated  that even  during the  and  territorial  integration  .The  Constitution.  When  the  Naga  I  still  hope  the  peace  talks  will  As for myself being a part of the
           COVID-19 pandemic the hospital is not close and still is open for the  question  as  to  what  makes  the  National Council (NNC) authority  deliver something to all  the  Naga  Zeliangrong,  I will  be more  than
           needy patient.                    results of Naga peace talks more so  was in its peak, Gaidinliu had to  tribes, but I’m left with little hope  content if any group in peace talks
              A similar announcement is made by Shija Hospital and Research  connected  with  the  Zeliangrong  suspend Zeliangrong movement for  as Interlocutor R. N. Ravi said even  could  bring  some  sort  of
           center by its  managing Director. After all, this hospital has proved  people comprise of Zeme, Liangmai,  homeland  due to intense  pressure  territorial  integration  is  dropped  administrative  autonomy  outside
           that they care more to save the life of patients in need by performing  Rongmei and Inpui tribe, living  in  from Zeliangrong leaders working  from  the  demands  of  Naga  the  administrative  control  of
           surgery without waiting for test results for COVID-19.  three state of Assam, Manipur and  in  NNC. The Zeliangrong  leaders  negotiators. With GoI and NNPGs  present  states  government  in
              When many of the health workers have been performing duty  Nagaland. Zeliangrong people were  felt that it would not be right to go  agreement, it is very likely that the  Assam and Manipur context, even
           taking all risk as it is  their performance,  many so-called self-style  recognized under different  names  against   the   Naga   cause  agreement would extend only within  when full integration of Zeliangrong
           intellectuals, or social workers brought up issues that may defame the  by the Schedules Tribe Order 1950  spearheaded  by  NNC  as  it  might  Nagaland state. And if speculations  people  could  not  be  achieved
           life  saviors. Well, not every doctor may have the same feeling of  and  its  subsequent  amendments.  create  a  sense  of  betrayal  by the  are true, Nagaland will see increase  straightaway.
           risking  their  lives  to  save   This article is an attempt to illustrate  Zeliangrong. Soon after suspension  of  State  Legislative Assembly  However, failing  to  achieve  even
           the  patient,  but  there  are    how the results of the current peace  of the Zeliangrong  movement, the  seats  and  parliamentary  seats,  administrative autonomy from  the
           countless of  them working        talks will have a huge implication  talks  between  Naga  People  establishment  of  legislative  peace talks, the Zeliangrong people
           with dedication.                  on the Zeliangrong people and their  Convention  and  GoI,  resulted  in  council.  Not  discrediting  the  need  to  seriously re-examine  the
              Sometimes,  people             ancestral  lands.  The irony  is  that  Naga  hills being upgraded  to full  influence  of  NNPGs  outside  sacrifices of their  people to Naga
           seem to have forgotten that       the  Zeliangrong  people  are  so  pledge  statehood  in  1963.  Even  Nagaland,  but  I  wonder  if  any  cause  by  not  only  studying  the
           doctors are no lesser God.        politically  divided  thanks  to  though  NNC  condemned  the  arrangement  made  for  Nagas  in  present  social,  economical,  and
           They  are  a  human  being        individual and local interests, crude  statehood,  their  condemnation  neighboring  states  would  see  the  political  conditions  of  the
           with  no  difference  from        regionalism, and blind  loyalty to  could  not  save  the  Zeliangrong  light  of  day.  Time  and  again  Zeliangrong  people  living in  the
           others. The only difference       their  own  factions  without  people   from   physical  NNPGs  have  stressed  that  they  three states of Assam, Manipur, and
           between  other  people  in        prudently discussing how to secure  disintegrations, blood brothers land  speak and remember the welfare of  Nagaland,  but  also  studying
           those  in  the  medical           the best interests for the people.  boundaries  with  few  inch  apart  Nagas in other states, but it is hard  whether continuing to sacrifice  for
           profession  is  that  they        In  modern  political  sense,  became  state  boundaries  further  to comprehend that NNPGs will fight  Naga cause will integrate its people.
           wanted to serve and  save         Zeliangrong consciousness as one  severing  their  historical  ties  and  tooth and nail to secure interests of  Lastly Zeliangrong people need to
           human lives.                      unit started with Haipou Jadonang  sympathy for each other. This was  Nagas outside Nagaland, even when  realize  India’s  political  realities
              Well, criticisms from          1905 -1931. After his untimely death  the  first  setback  to  Zeliangrong  the so-called Naga nationalists has  before it is too late, that India will
           those who have fewer ideas        the burden of fulfilling Zeliangrong  fraternity. Even after the Statehood  taken regionalism to a new level. In  remain  a  difficult  place  for  the
           of the difficulties  faced by     political interests was passed on to  and  Shillong Accord  under  the  such  a reality,  Zeliangrongs  have  minorities to survive, and worst in
           doctors  and  nurses  is          his successor late Apeh Gaidinliu  Indian   Constitution,   the  very nominal or nothing to achieve  tribal state.
           normal, but when a doctor in the same profession mock and criticize
           the dedication of a doctor, than it is jealousy. The person, a doctor,
           and who is also a senior most doctor of RIMS mocking Dr. Uthan  Modi redefined secularism with Ram Mandir as
           who collapsed due  to exhaustion is very unfortunate.
              If senior doctors, who mock the hard work of a junior doctor
           is let free, then many who had wanted to serve the people may be  Hindu voters were fed up of Sonia-Left version
           discouraged.  It  is  expected  that  junior  doctors  of  his institution
           (RIMS) may have been discouraged by this doctor, and authorities  By - SHEKHAR GUPTA   that new destination with sex appeal  that  we  could  foresee May  2014,  Mayawati’s  BSP  took  turns  in
           of RIMS need an immediate inquiry into this matter.  Or else there  (Courtesy – The Print )  for some, Turkey. We have to live in  May 2019 and now 5 August 2020,  power.
           are also possibilities  that he being  ahead of the department may  an  India governed by whoever the  being scripted. I wrote two National  Both built their new politics around
           advise  students  and  junior  doctors  at  RIMS  not  to  render  their  Did  Indian  secularism  die  on  5  people choose, based on the same  Interest pieces, in the wake of the  the  redefined  ‘secular’  vote.  In
           valuable service during this crisis time.  If the comment by him at  August  in Ayodhya?  It  follows,  Constitution we hold so dear.  2002 and  2007  Gujarat  elections,  Bihar,  Lalu Yadav  had  already
           FB  was  a  doctored  one  than  he  needs  to  take  the  help  of  the  then,  that a  new  Indian  Republic  In the past 35 years, secularism has  anticipating  the  inevitable  and  perfected the formula. The secular
           cybercrime police.                would have been invented, a Hindu  been pronounced dead by the Right  unstoppable rise of Narendra Modi  vote now came to be seen as Muslim
                                             Rashtra.          after  Rajiv Gandhi’s action  on the  as a dominant national leader (‘The  vote.
                                             If you accept those two arguments,  Shah  Bano  case  (1986),  the  Modi Magnifier’, and ‘If Modi wins  It was around this new notion that
                                             a  third  becomes  inevitable. Any  proactive   ban   on Satanic  on Sunday’). The second even said  old  enemies  came  together  in
             Imphal Times needs your support  Indian with a belief  in our secular  Verses (1988), the unlocking of the  Modi’s short-sleeved kurtas would  unlikely coalitions to keep the BJP
                                             Constitution can then say this isn’t  gates  of  Babri  Masjid-Ram  become  a  political  fashion  out of power. The two United Front
             Imphal Times is an English evening daily published in  the country I was born in. And, I am  Janmabhoomi,  Shilanyas and the  statement.  coalitions  on  daily  wages,  under
           Imphal. The newspaper bearing RNI No. MANENG /  going away. To America, where else,  launch  of  the  national  election  Am  I a Modi  fan, or  to  use  that  H.D. Deve Gowda and I.K. Gujral,
                                                               campaign from Ayodhya with  the
                                             but only once Donald Trump goes
                                                                                                  were both an arrogant negation of
                                                                                 expression fashionable these days,
           2013/51092 also runs a web page www.imphaltimes.com  this  winter  and  immigration  eases  promise of Ram Rajya (1989).  a  ‘bhakt’?  Not  even  Modi  will  the popular will. The only time this
           and is also the first news organization to launch Android  up.  Then, in 1992, with the destruction  accuse  me  of  that.  But  I  am  a  new  post-1992  “anybody  but  the
           App in the state of Manipur. We also have a team to promote  To be  upfront,  we  dismiss  all  of  of  the  mosque,  followed  by  journalist with eyes and ears open.  BJP”  secular formulation  won  a
           our news content through Social networking sites like  these assumptions as bunk. First of  widespread communal riots. What  Indian secularism was pronounced  genuine mandate was in 2009.
           Facebook, Twitter, Instagram etc.  all,  the  rumours  of  the  death  of  else could you expect from a prime  dead in 2014 and again in 2019. But  The reason  we call the post-1992
             Besides our hard copy circulation our web site is visited  secularism are just  that,  rumours,  minister   who   “wore  on 5 August, that is earlier this week,  secularism  a  new  formulation  is
                                                               khaki chaddi (RSS shorts) under his
                                                                                 it was still alive to be killed yet again.
                                             and vastly exaggerated too. Sorry,
                                                                                                  because  of  how  strongly  Left
           regularly from across 152 different countries around the  Mark Twain, to drag you into the  dhoti?” Arjun  Singh drafted Sonia  But  hang  on,  you  might  say, this  politics  and  intelligentsia  got
           world. Around 30,000 plus individuals had downloaded  messiest  side  of  our  politics.  Gandhi to  come in with Sanjivani  time I  have  seen  its  corpse. You  involved  in  it.  They  rewrote the
           our Android App.                  Second, the death of secularism has  Booti, but that had short-lived effect  would be right.  Ayodhya binary as: Did Ram even
             As generating revenue is now become compulsory to  been  announced  several  times  in Kaliyuga. Indian secularism was  Something  did  indeed  die  this  5  exist  or not? This  ran contrary  to
           run our news organization we need your support. Your little  before; on a rough count, about as  again  pronounced  dead  in  1996,  August in Ayodhya. It is just that it  the  Congress  party’s  cautious
           contribution  by  subscribing  our  newspaper  and  by  often as our commando comic TV  when Atal  Bihari  Vajpayee  put  wasn’t   our   constitutional  approach  where  minorities  were
                                                                                 secularism,  but  a  version  of  it
                                                                                                  patronised,  but  Hinduism  never
                                                               together  India’s  first  BJP-led
                                             channels declare  Dawood Ibrahim
           advertising for promotion of your products or business will  dead.  government, even if it lasted just 13  confected after December 1992.  mocked.
           help us serve you more.           Sorry for that odd comparison. But  days. It was three more than what  That the Babri demolition  and the  If  the  new BJP  was  dyed  deeper
             Please sent message at whatsapp No. 9862860745  a rumour is a rumour is a rumour. Of  Congress   party’s   affable  riots that followed angered a lot of  saffron, the Congress-led alliance’s
                                             course, it is fun if you are a masochist  spokesman then, V.N. Gadgil, had  middle-of-the-road Hindus also is a  secularism was now much redder. It
                                             and relish self-flagellation.  predicted  it  to  be,  a  “ten-day  fact proven by election results that  led  to  a  series  of  blunders:  The
                                             A very vast majority, in fact almost  wonder”.  followed. This was especially so in  abolition of POTA  (Prevention of
           Letters,  Feedback  and  Suggestions  to  ‘Imphal  Times’  all of the 138-plus crore of us here,  The next time Indian secularism died  the  Hindi  heartland,  particularly  Terrorism Act), as a pre-condition
           can be sent to our e-mail : imphaltimes@gmail.com. For advertisement  have no green cards or benevolent  was in the Gujarat killings of 2002,  Uttar Pradesh. After Kalyan Singh’s  to the formation of UPA-1, because
           kindy contact:  -  0385-3590330 (O).  For time being readers can reach the  uncles  or  foundations  waiting to  and  then  died  again and again  as  BJP  government  was  dismissed,  the ‘Muslims’ felt victimised. Never
           office at Cell Phone No. 9862860745 for any purpose.  take us to America. Or Europe. Or  Modi kept winning there. It was then  Mulayam  Singh Yadav’s  SP  and  (Contd. on Page 3)
   33   34   35   36   37   38   39   40   41   42   43