Page 414 - IBC Orders us 7-CA Mukesh Mohan
P. 414

Order Passed by Sec 7
               Hon’ble NCLT Allahabad Bench
                       Further, the Hon'ble NCLAT, in the very same case before, it has ruled that the 'Adjudicating

               Authority' on receipt of the application under Section 7 sub-section (2) is required Lo ascertain existence
               of  default  on  the  basis  of  evidence  furnished  by  the  Financial  Creditor  under  sub-section  (3).  The
               'adjudicating authority' is required to satisfy three things Occurrence of default; application is complete

               and  no  disciplinary  proceedings  is  pending  against  the  proposed  Insolvency  Resolution  Professional.
               Beyond the aforesaid practice, this 'Adjudicating Authority' is not required to look into any other factor;

               including the question whether permission or consent is obtained from one or other authority, including
               1/w JLF (Joint Lender's forum)."


                       Further, the Hon'ble Allahabad High Court in its recent decision in the matter of Sanjeev Shriya
               v/s State Bank of India & 6 Ors. (Writ-C No. 30285/2017) and in connected case Deepak Singhania &
               Anr. v/s State Bank of India (Writ-C No. 30033 of 2017) has also held that the provision of I & B Code

               would prevail over the provisions of DRT proceedings by observing (in the relevant para nos. 21,24, 29,
               31, & 32 of the judgment) as such:-


                              21. Section 60 .simulates that they Adjudicating A mill o thy, in relation to insolvency
                              resolution  and liquidation for  emporate  per including  corporate  debtors  and  personal
                              guarapptors  thereof;  shall  be  the  National  Company  Law  Tribunal  having  territorial

                              jurisdiction over die place where the registered office the 7orporate person is located. s
                              per provisions contained under Section 60 qf the IBC, 201 the National Company Law
                              Tribunal shall he die Adjudicating A tiff, on for Insolvency resolution and I liquidation of

                              corporate  debtors  and  also  lays  down  the  criteria  for  establishing  the  territorial
                              jurisdiction  of  the  Tribunal.  The  insolvency  resolution  or  bankruptcy  proceedings

                              relating  to  a  personal  guarantor  of  a  corporate  debtor  shall  also  be  filed  before  the
                              National Company Law Tribunal


                              24. The object of [SC. 2016 is. categorical and as per provisions contained under Section
                              60(1) the Adjudicating Authority, in relation to in resolution and liquidation fir corporate
                              persons  including  corporate  debtors  and  personal  guarantors.  thereof  shall  be  the

                              National Company Law Tribunal. In the present matter, ,leinrittedly the proceeding has
                              been initiated under the /BC, 1 and the Moratorium Under Section 14 of the IBC, 201 has
                              already  been  issued  b  the  NUE  The  NCLT  is  already  ceased  with  the  process  of

                              Insolvency resolution against the company (in 14.) under IBC, 201 and moreover, the SRI
                              has also put their appearance in the said proceedings regarding its claim. Ai no point of






               414
   409   410   411   412   413   414   415   416   417   418   419