Page 24 - NYS_ESS_05-2026
P. 24

following strategies to offset the likelihood of perpetuating AI   Conclusion
      fabrications and minimize the risks if you choose to use AI to   AI is not going anywhere. While AI appears to have many
      research the law.
                                                             benefits, all that glitters is not gold. I hope the examples in
      Knowledge and education are key. Awareness that AI may  this article serve as a deterrent for misuse of AI, rather than a
      fabricate information when performing research and analysis   warning of what is to come for the surveying profession as AI
      of the law better arms you to offset the hazards associated with   use increases. Exercise caution to safeguard your work, your
      AI fabrications. Discuss AI limitations and use cases with other   reputation, and your clients.
      surveyors and educate others often.
                                                             You have your license, experience, and professional judgment,
      Verify any legal precedent obtained from AI. One method   and you will likely be held liable for any AI-generated
      of verification is to obtain and read the legal opinion. There   fabrications in your work. AI has no conscience, no morals, no
      are many ways to find state and federal legal opinions, and   ethics, and no emotions. AI won’t feel ashamed for providing
      probably the most easily accessible is Google Scholar’s case law   you with false information, it won’t feel guilty for getting you
      search function. However, not all cases are available on Google
      Scholar and it may be hard to verify whether a case is still good   in trouble, and it won’t be held accountable. Intelligence that
      law on the issue you are researching, as Google Scholar does not   is artificial, indeed.
      have a comprehensive citator service that tracks the history and  Note: No generative artificial intelligence was used in writing
      subsequent decisions regarding the case. Databases specifically  this article. Information contained within this article is not legal
      designed for legal research, such as  Westlaw, LexisNexis, or  advice and does not establish an attorney-client relationship.
      Fastcase, have a larger repository of cases and more nuanced  The opinions in this article are the author’s own and do not
      citator services.                                      represent the position or opinions of the author’s employer.

      Enlist an attorney. Legal research is complex and good law must   About the Author:
      be verified. Especially if you are involved with a particularly   From teaching university classes to digging fire line,  Vailferree
      difficult or complex issue, the help of a competent attorney is   Brechtel has extensive education and experience in natural resources
      well worth the price to avoid AI fabrications and any associated   and environmental management, law, communication, conflict
      consequences to your reputation or licensure.          resolution, surveying, and literature. She is licensed in Alaska as

      If you consult with an attorney, ask the attorney to provide  an attorney and a Professional Land Surveyor. She works as a
      acknowledgements or disclaimers. An acknowledgement of AI   surveyor at the Alaska Department of Natural Resources, Division
      use should contain, at the least, details of how AI was used   of Mining, Land & Water, where she tackles boundary issues at the
      and whether information generated by AI was verified by a   intersection of surveying, law, and land management.
      qualified human. If AI wasn’t used, the attorney may include
      a disclaimer stating that no artificial intelligence was used to   1.  Top 5 AI Tools Transforming the Work of Surveyors
      create the document.                                   2.  Modern Land Surveying: Revolutionizing Techniques with AI
      Consider using acknowledgements or disclaimers of AI use   3.  Deed Reader Pro
      for your own work. Sources of information for the work you  4.  AI at the Boundary – The American Surveyor
      produce should be documented and verifiable. With the uptick  5.  Judge disqualifies three Butler Snow attorneys from case over AI
      of AI manipulated images, you may find it good practice to   citations | Reuters
      offer a suitable acknowledgement or disclaimer. This may   6.  California issues historic fine over lawyer’s ChatGPT fabrications
      provide assurance to clients, and the courts, of the integrity of   7.  Massachusetts Lawyer Sanctioned for AI-Generated Fictitious
      the survey work.
                                                                Case Citations | Maryland State Bar Association
      Be  mindful  that  inputting  information  into AI  may  create   8.  NetChoice Pulls Expert After Allegations of AI Fabrications (1)
      confidentiality  or privacy  concerns. Great care should  be   9.  When AI Hallucinations Become Expert Testimony: A Warning
      exercised in what you share,  especially in the context of active   Tale for Litigators | Maryland State Bar Association
                             11
      litigation.
                                                             10. Disqualifying Lawyers Over Expert’s AI Misuse Too Harsh,
      Depending on your state’s definition of the practice of   Plaintiff Says — Mealey’s
      law, exercise caution and confirm with legal counsel so that   11. 5 Things You Should Never Share with ChatGPT — AgileBlue
      unauthorized practice of law does not occur. Consider seeking
      out an attorney to provide your professional organization with  Thank you to  The American Surveyor magazine. This article
      education on legal research, the definition of the practice of  originally appeared on their website on February 1, 2026 and
      law, or insights regarding AI use for legal research or subject  can be  found at  https://amerisurv.com/2026/02/01/cautionary-
      matter experts involved in litigation.                 tales-of-ai-use-in-legal-research/.


      22   EMPIRE STATE SURVEYOR / VOL. 62 • NO 3 / 2026 • MAY/JUNE
   19   20   21   22   23   24   25   26   27   28   29