Page 955 - SUBSEC October 2017_Neat
P. 955

- 2 -
                                                                                02231032/CAPE/KMS 2017
                                                           LAW
                                                  UNIT 2 Paper 032
                                                KEY AND MARK SCHEME

                                                 STRICT LIABILITY

             Specific Objective: 6

             (a)    Candidates  are  expected  to  explain  ‘strict  liability’  in  tort
                    including the key elements

                    Definition:

                      Automatic responsibility for damages due to possession and/or use
                       of  equipment,  materials  or  possessions  which  are  inherently
                       dangerous such as explosives, wild animals, poisonous snakes, or
                       assault weapons.

                      Defendant  is  liable  even  though  the  damage  to  the  plaintiff
                       occurred  without  intention  or  negligence/fault  on  defendant’s
                       part.

                      Motive of the defendant is irrelevant.

                      It does not matter what sort of precautions the defendant takes.

                      The primary basis of liability is the creation of an extraordinary
                       risk.

                      If the activity is appropriate to the area, strict liability exists
                       only if the activity is conducted in an unusual or abnormal way.

                      A deterrent aspect of tort, aimed at inducing persons to modify
                       their behaviour so as to avoid harming others.

                    Any other relevant point
                    Any three points clearly explained 2 marks each           [6 marks]
                    Clear explanation including only one point 2 marks
                    Weak explanation 1 mark

                    Example of Strict Liability

                    Liability for animals

                    -   Test: called Scienter, that is, owner liable for harm caused by
                       the animal. The type of action is called a scienter action.

                    -   Because animals are not governed by a conscience and possess great
                       capacity to do mischief if not restrained, those who keep animals
                       have a duty to restrain them.

                    -   In  most  jurisdictions  the  general  rule  is  that  keepers  of  all
                       animals,  including  domesticated  ones,  are  strictly  liable  for
                       damage resulting from the trespass of their animals on the property
                       of another.
   950   951   952   953   954   955   956   957   958   959   960