Page 49 - 2020 October 8 HK Fine Classical Paintings

2575
REN RENFA 1255-1328 9) Sherman E. Lee and Wai-Kam Ho, “Jen Jen-Fa: Three
Horses and Four Grooms” in The Bulletin of the Cleveland
Five Drunken Princes Returning on Horseback Museum of Art, 1961, p.72, note 4.
ink and colour on paper, handscroll 10) James Cahill, An Index of Early Chinese Painters and
Paintings: Tang, Song and Yuan, Los Angeles, University of
with two seals of the artist California Press, 1980, p.287.
Colophon by Chen Jiru(1558-1639) and with two seals of his; 11) Xu Bangda, “Liutan Gushuhua Jianbie (Six Discussions on
by Wang Yongji(?-1653), dated renshen(1632) the identification of Ancient Calligraphy and Painting)”, see
with one collector’s seal of Zhu Shangbin(1555-1623), eight Palace Museum Journal, 1981, issue 03, p. 73
collector’s seals of Liang Qingbiao(1620-1691), five collector’s 12) Yang Renkai, Guobao chenfu lu : Gugong sanyi shuhua 2575
seals of Geng Zhaozhong(1640-1686), eight seals of Qianlong jianwen kaolue (‘Record of the Vicissitudes of National
Emperor, including Shiqu baoji(‘The Precious Collection of Treasures: Investigation of the Dispersed and Lost
the Stone Canal Pavilion’), one seal of Jiaqing Emperor, three Calligraphies and Paintings from the Former Palace that I have
seals of Xuantong Emperor, three collector’s seals of Walter seen and Heard about’), Beijing, 1992, p. 551.
Hochstadter(1914-2007) and seven other collectors’ seals 13) Xu Bangda, Chongding Qing Gugong Jiucang Shuhua Lu,
210.7 by 35.2 cm. 83 by 13⅞ in. Beijing, 1997, p. 66 任仁發 五王醉歸圖 公未及詳核，因附記於此。崇禎壬申 (1632) 二月之七
14) Xu Bangda, Gushuhua Guoyan Yaolu: Yuan Ming Qing
LITERATURE Paintings, 2006, p.101 日，輞川館主人記。
1) Zhang Ning, “Wu Ruhui Ren Yueshan Gongzi Zuiguitu”, see 15) Liu Jinku, Nanhua Beidu: Qingdai Shuhua Jiancang 設色紙本 手卷 鑑藏印：
Zhang Ning, Fangzhouji, juan 6 Zhongxin Yanjiu, 2008, p.293, no. 427 鈐印：「任氏子明」、「月山道人」
2) Cheng Minzheng, “Ren Yueshan Wu Wang Zui Gui Tu”, see (朱尚賓)「尚賓」(半印)
Cheng Minzheng, Huangdun Wenji, juan 82 PROVENANCE 題跋： (梁清標)「蕉林玉立氏圖書」、「觀其大略」、「安定」
3) Chen Jiru, “Ba Tangren Ma Juan”, see Chen Mengpeng and Previously from Wu Qiong, Wang Yongji, Liang Qingbiao, Geng (陳繼儒)唐文皇石刻昭陵六馬，故子孫多馬癖，代宗有九 、「蕉林秘玩」、「蒼岩」、「蒼岩子」、「棠邨審定」
Wu Zhenyuan edit, Chen Meigong Xiansheng Quanji, juan 50 Zhaozhong’s Collection 花虯，德宗有神智驄、如意騮。飾以黃金勒，控以紫玉 、「河北棠邨」
4) Shiqu baoji xubian (‘Sequel to The Precious Collection of the Qing Imperial Court Collection 鞭，豢以一品料。故其圖流傳人間，歌詠不絕。此卷唐人 (耿昭忠)「耿昭忠信公氏一字在良別號長白山長收藏書畫
Stone Canal Pavilion’), Stored in Qianqinggong, (the Palace of Collection of Henry Puyi (1906-1967), last emperor of China 印」、「信公鑒定珍藏」(三鈐)、「半古軒書畫印」
Celestial Purity), no. 6. C.T.Loo 筆，題跋剪截已去，幸人馬尚爾平安，無錫王麟郊先生世 (乾隆皇帝)「乾隆御覽之寶」、「乾隆鑑賞」、「石渠寶
5) Ruan Yuan, Shiqu Shubi, juan 4, pp.2-3 Walter Hochstadter 藏，其孫福州守曼修公能永護之，環回諦玩，姿態毛骨如
6) Sun Yueban, Wang Yuanqi, Peiwenzhai Shuhuapu, juan 65, Christie’s Hong Kong, Fine Classical Chinese Painting and 生，所謂寫渥窪之狀，不在水中，移騕褭之形，出於天 笈」、「石渠定鑑」、「寶笈重編」、「三希堂精鑑璽」
“Tangren Majuan” Calligraphy, 29 November 2009, lot 815 上。定為曹霸所作，即公麟輩未能與之絕塵而爭驅也。雲 、「乾清宮鑒藏寶」、「宜子孫」
7) Shang Pu Jie shuhua mu (‘Treasures Bestowed to Pu Jie’), 間陳繼儒題於頑仙廬。鈐印：「眉道人」、「陳繼儒印」 (嘉慶皇帝)「嘉慶御覽之寶」
p.13. (宣統皇帝)「宣統御覽之寶」、「宣統鑑賞」、「無逸齋
8) Chen Rentao, et al., Gugong yi shi shuhua mu jiaozhu (‘Notes HK$ 80,000,000-120,000,000 (王永吉)此卷予既請眉公先生題識，信其筆法之妙非近代 精鑒璽」
on Paintings and Calligraphy Lost from the Forbidden City’), US$ 10,340,000-15,510,000 丹青家所辨。獨云：出自唐人手，未有確據，考其楮尾印 (侯士泰)「侯士泰鑑藏」、「天目山人」、「尊古堂真
Hong Kong, 1956, p. 3. 章二：一「任氏子明」，一「月山道人」。暇日偶閱李九
疑紫桃軒雜綴，廼知為元人任水監也，按雜綴云：元任仁 賞」
發，字子明，號月山，世居松之青龍鎮，年十八中鄊試 「驚鴻閣」(半印)、「中立」(半印)、「立」(半印)、「忠
貳，都水監開江置閘，凡水議，仁發主之。善繪事，嘗奉 信可久安」(半印)、「輙相思」(半印)、「可以觀」(半印)
、「子孫」(半印)
旨入內畫《渥窪天馬圖》。所著有水利書十卷。今人止稱
任水監，畫馬蓋以藝掩云。然則任以畫馬得名甚著，而眉

94 FOR COMPLETE CATALOGUING 詳盡圖錄內容請瀏覽 SOTHEBYS.COM/HK0971 95