Page 64 - bne_August 2020_20200810

64 Opinion
Turkey: Net Portfolio Flows to Borsa Istanbul vs BIST-100
bne August 2020
Turkey: Net Portfolio Flows to Domestic Government Bonds vs 2-year Benchmark Yield
Turkey’s weight in the MSCI Emerging Markets Index is below 1% and in the MSCI ACWI, excluding the US, and the MSCI ACWI global indices it is close to zero.
On June 23, S&P Global Ratings said that it had classified Turkey’s banking sector in its assessment framework in the same group as the banking sectors of Azerbaijan, Egypt, Kazakhstan, Greece, Bangladesh and Argentina. It took
a swipe at the checks and balances within the Turkish institutional system, describing them as weak. Questions remained about the quality of regulation and the perceived independence of the watchdog and the central bank, it said.
Fitch Ratings rates Turkey at BB-/Stable, three notches below investment grade. Moody’s Rating Services rates Turkey at B1/Negative, four notches below investment grade, while Standard & Poor’s has Turkey at B+/Stable, also four notches below investment grade.
Fitch’s second rating review release for Turkey is expected on August 21. Moody’s second review is scheduled for December 4, while S&P is set to release its last scheduled review for this year on July 24.
Moody’s Investor Services previously scheduled a Turkey sovereign rating review for June 5 but that date has been put back. In its latest rating action on Turkey, in June last year, Moody’s issued a downgrade to B1, four notches below investment grade, with a negative outlook.
On June 15, Moody’s Investors Service said that it had downgraded Turkey’s flag carrier, Turkish Airlines, to B3, six notches below investment grade, from B2.
Turkey, with its B+/Stable rating by S&P, sits alongside Benin, Bolivia, Jordan, Kenya, Rwanda, Senegal and Bahrain.
Bolivia and Tanzania have B1/Negative ratings from Moody’s too while Fitch sees Bahrain, Bangladesh, Guatemala and Uzbekistan at BB-/Stable.
On June 18, ING Bank said in a research note that it saw
a possible turning point in foreign investors’ interest in Turkish
www.bne.eu
domestic government bonds occurring by mid-July when the recent deal between Brussels-based Euroclear Bank and the Turkish Finance Ministry comes into effect.
As of June 24, the last transaction in Turkey’s 2-year benchmark papers had occurred on June 22.
According to Mercan and Pham, the Euroclear deal “should be a signal of the government’s interest to attract portfolio flows and commitment to free movements of capital.”
This, it must be said, does not reflect the Turkey of today, given the market machinations of the Erdogan regime. It has no grounding in reality.
We are doing journalism in the post-truth age. Politicians pursue their manipulations and no one is surprised, for they are politicians, but those of us supposedly not buying into the Orwellian deceit need to hold on to verifiable facts for dear life.
On June 19, Moody’s said that it had decided to withdraw the ratings of ING Bank Turkey for its own business reasons.
“Business Reasons – Under certain circumstances, Moody's will withdraw a rating for an issuer or an obligation for reasons unrelated to the adequacy of information, or bankruptcy or reorganization status of the credit. When this occurs, Moody's will balance the market need for a rating against the resources required to maintain and monitor
a rating,” according to Moody’s guidelines.
In March, Bloomberg quoted some unnamed sources as saying that ING Groep NV, the biggest Dutch lender, was considering a sale of its Turkish business.
ING has not officially denied the report.
According to ING’s macroeconomic research notes, the Turkish economy is doing pretty well and a huge inflow of portfolio investments is on the way.
ING does not release research on banking regulations in Turkey.