Page 141 - Technology Roadmap Transportation
P. 141

TECHNOLOGY ROADMAP: TRANSPORTATION




                             in motive power and needs to be developed   Government as well as industry. India has the
                             indigenously. Very recently, an Indian Company has   knowledge base and wherewithal to do it, only
                             succeeded in developing IGBT based propulsion   the right agencies are to be brought together and
                             drives of 4.5MW capacity, which is being used in   strategized. The technology that would be needed
                             commercial operation. This is a silver lining, and   in the next two decades for entering into high
                             creates confidence that capability exists in India.   speed operation (but not limited to).
                             However commercialization of those advanced
                             technologies can be possible through synergetic
                             partnership between Academia, R&D institutes,



             FIG 2.4: COMPARISON OF MAGLEV WITH HIGH SPEED TRAIN TECHNOLOGY[11].




                                            Travel Time                  Travel Time





                                                                     300-350 km/h



                                                                                      Excellent /
                                                                                  extensive networks
                                                           420-450 km/h
                                               speed range
                                                 Higher at upper
                                                                                    New Lines combined with
                                    None/ single lines
                                                                                existing line stations can be used


                             New and elevated guide ways,
                            tunnel and stations needed
                                                                                  $6-25 million/km
                                 $12-55 million/km
                                                     MAGLEV          HSR

                                 Uncertain                                               Known

                                    Higher than HSR




                                                Excellent, plus initial   Lower noise and vibration  Tracks mostly at grade  network accessibility  Superior
                                                  innovation interest





                                                                           Excellent / superior


                                                                                   Additional factors


                                        Additional factors









                                                                                                        RAILWAYS   139
   136   137   138   139   140   141   142   143   144   145   146