Page 31 - AD
P. 31

PEOPLE & ARTS A31
                                                                                                                                                Tuesday 12 April 2016

                                                                                      Judge clears ‘Stairway to
                                                                                      Heaven’ copyright case for trial 

  In an Aug. 19, 2006 file photo, television personality and dog                      ANTHONY McCARTNEY                In this Oct. 9, 2012 file photo, members of Led Zeppelin, guitarist
psychologist Cesar Milan arrives for the Creative Arts Emmy                           AP Entertainment Writer         Jimmy Page, left, and singer Robert Plant appear at a press con-
Awards in Los Angeles.                                                                LOS ANGELES (AP) — A trial      ference ahead of the worldwide theatrical release of “Celebra-
                                                                                      is needed to determine if       tion Day”, a concert film of their 2007 London O2 arena reunion
                                                                    Associated Press  Led Zeppelin’s “Stairway to     show, in New York. 
                                                                                      Heaven” copies its open-
No charges against TV’s                                                               ing notes from a song per-                                                                          Associated Press
‘Dog Whisperer’ Cesar Millan                                                          formed by the rock band
                                                                                      Spirit, a federal judge has
JOHN ANTCZAK                     the animals together in a                            ruled. U.S District Judge R.    email messages sent to          one of the most recogniz-
Associated Press                 yard. A Change.org peti-                             Gary Klausner ruled Friday      Helene M. Freeman, Led          able song introductions in
LOS ANGELES (AP) — No            tion called on Nat Geo                               that lawyers for the trustee    Zeppelin’s attorney, were       rock history.
charges will be brought          WILD to take the show                                of late Spirit guitarist Randy  not immediately returned.       Skidmore was able to over-
against TV “Dog Whisper-         off the air, calling Millan’s                        Wolfe had shown enough          Experts hired by the band       come statute-of-limitations
er” Cesar Millan following       methods inhumane.                                    evidence to support a case      contend both “Stairway to       hurdles to sue over “Stair-
an investigation of animal       The county Department of                             that “Stairway to Heaven”       Heaven” and “Taurus” use        way to Heaven” because
cruelty complaints involv-       Animal Care and Control                              copies music from the Spirit    notes that have been used       the song was remastered
ing an episode in which a        independently investigat-                            song “Taurus.”                  in music for centuries.         and re-released in 2014.
dog nipped a pig’s ear, au-      ed and concluded the pig                             “Taurus” was written by         Francis Alexander Malofiy,      A jury trial is scheduled
thorities said Monday.           “is fine and has no discern-                         Wolfe in either 1966 or 1967,   attorney for Wolfe’s trustee    for May 10 in Los Angeles.
The investigation showed         able injury to its ear,” the                         years before Led Zeppe-         Michael Skidmore, praised       Klausner’s ruling removed
the dog accidentally es-         evaluation said.                                     lin released “Stairway to       the ruling. He said while       Zeppelin band member
caped Millan’s control,          Millan said in a statement                           Heaven” in 1971. Klausner       many copyright cases are        John Paul Jones from the
and people present in-           that he was pleased but                              wrote that while the songs      an uphill battle, Klausner’s    case. Bandmates Robert
stantly captured the dog,        not surprised by the deci-                           have some differences,          ruling brings his client one    Plant and Jimmy Page re-
attended to the pig and          sion.                                                lawyers for Wolfe’s trustee     step closer to getting Wolfe    main defendants in the
called in a veterinarian,        “Our animal handling pro-                            may be able to prove they       credit for helping create       case. q
who found there was no           cedures are safe and hu-                             are substantially similar.
need for treatment, Los An-      mane. ... I am continuing                            Led Zeppelin and Spirit per-
geles County Deputy Dis-         my work rescuing and re-                             formed at some concerts
trict Attorney David Jacobs      habilitating even the most                           and festivals around the
wrote in a case evaluation       difficult problem dogs,                              same time, but not on the
statement.                       which has saved the lives                            same stage. Klausner wrote
“There is no evidence that       of thousands of animals                              that the evidence present-
the pig was used as bait,        that otherwise would have                            ed so far represented a cir-
and all parties who wit-         been euthanized,” Millan                             cumstantial case that Led
nessed the incident felt         said.                                                Zeppelin may have heard
it was an accident,” the         The dog trainer has said he                          “Taurus” performed before
evaluation said. “Although       has used the same tech-                              “Stairway to Heaven” was
in the video the pig is seen     nique to help aggressive                             created.
bleeding, the dog’s act          canines hundreds of times.                           After-hours phone and
was merely a nip and did         The training involves get-
not tear or bite the skin off.”  ting the dog together with                           The Weeknd , Bieber
The complaint was started        the animal it doesn’t like so
online and based on foot-        the two can learn to get                             earn Billboard Music
age from Millan’s television     along.
show “Cesar 911,” in which       Millan’s attorney, Brian                             Award nominations 
a French bulldog-terrier mix     Klein, said his client cooper-
named Simon was under-           ated throughout the inves-                           LOS ANGELES (AP) — It’s a       and his collaboration with       In this Feb. 15, 2016 file photo,
going behavior modifica-         tigation.                                            sweet day to be The Week-       Future on “What A Time To       The Weeknd appears at the
tion because it had a his-       “We were always confident                            nd. The R&B artist is leading   Be Alive.”                      58th annual Grammy Awards
tory of attacking other ani-     that Animal Control would                            the nominees at this year’s     Adele and Taylor Swift are      in Los Angeles.
mals, including its owner’s      conclude that Cesar and                              Billboard Music Awards          tied with eight nominations,
pigs.                            his team did nothing wrong                           with 16 nods in categories      including top artist, top fe-                      Associated Press
Simon chased and nipped          and that there would be                              such as top artist, top hot     male artist, top Billboard 200
the pig after Millan placed      no charges,” he said.q                               100 song and top Billboard      artist and top Billboard 200    artist award.
                                                                                      200 album.                      album — all of which Swift      Billboard Music Awards
                                                                                      Justin Bieber is following      won at last year’s ceremo-      hosts Ludacris and Ci-
                                                                                      behind the “Can’t Feel My       ny. The Weeknd’s “Beauty        ara announced some of
                                                                                      Face” singer with 11 nomi-      Behind The Madness” is up       the nominees Monday
                                                                                      nations, including top artist   for the top Billboard 200 al-   on ABC’s “Good Morning
                                                                                      and top male artist.            bum against Adele’s “25,”       America.” q
                                                                                      Fetty Wap and Drake are         Justin Bieber’s “Purpose,”
                                                                                      each up for 10 awards.          Ed Sheeran’s “x’’ and Tay-
                                                                                      Drake will compete against      lor Swift’s “1989.”
                                                                                      himself in the top rap album    The Weeknd, Bieber and
                                                                                      category with “If You’re        Drake will compete against
                                                                                      Reading This It’s Too Late”     Adele and Swift for the top
   26   27   28   29   30   31   32