Page 16 - Met Museum Ghandara Incense Burner
P. 16

Figure 29.  Relief on the interior of the lid of a  shell-shaped
              Figure 27.  Incense burner.  Egypt,  1st  century  a.  d. Bronze,   box. Tarentum,  Italy,  Hellenistic.  Silver,  diam.  4  cm. Museo
              H.  24.8  cm. Collection of Lewis M. Dubroff  (photo: courtesy   Archeologico Nazionale,  Taranto  (photo:  Henri-Paul Franc-
                                                                           du Gandhara  [Paris,  1979], pl. 19a)
              Sotheby's)                                        fort,  Les  palettes


                                                                form  easily  understood as the Indian  pipal,  which
                                                                appears  on the lid of the Gandharan burner  (see
                                                                Figure 9).  We shall show other, similar  Greek-style
                                                                burners  which  have  been  discovered  in  or  are
                                                                believed to have come from  places  in  proximity  to
                                                                the sea route to India.
                                                                  As one would  expect   from  reading  the   Periplus,
                                                                Egypt  was the best source for  objects  which were sent
                                                                to India. Two incense burners from Tuch  el-Karamus
                                                                in  Egypt  are related to the Gandharan burner  in that
                                                                they  have fluted stems,  albeit much heavier in form.
                                                                The first of the two  (Figure  24)  is of the same  type  as
                                                                             Greek
                                                                the  Levy-White    example (Figure  23),  with  four
                                                                winged figures  on the base.67 The  major  difference is
                                                                that the base of the  Egyptian
                                                                                         burner  is rounded rather
                                                                than  square,  and a lid  pierced  to look like  basketry
                                                                                                            has
                                                                been found to  go  with it  (Figure  25).  On the flat  top
                                                                of the handle of the Tuch el-Karamus lid sat a hen
                                                                (or rooster?)  which is no  longer  attached  but can be
                                                                seen in the reconstruction  (Figure  26).  A late Gand-
                                                                haran  version  of  this  vessel  that  looks  like  an
                                                                inverted Chinese bowl was excavated at Taxila.68
                                                                The lid is similar,  but the  basketry  has become an
                                                                inverted lotus,  and the four  winged figures  which
                                                                support  the base have been  transformed into ele-
                                                                phants.  Another incense burner,  from the collection
                                                                of  Lewis Dubroff   (Figure 27),   is said to be from
              Figure  28. Incense burner.  Tarentum,  Italy,  3rd century  B.C.   and was   in Roman times. Here one
              Silver.  Collection of Edmond  de Rothschild  (photo:  Michael   Egypt   produced
              Pfrommer,  Studien zu alexandrinischer und  grossgriechischer   can see, at a later date, the  tenacity  of the  tapering
              Toreutik          Zeit  [Berlin,  1987],  pl. 32)   fluted column with a torus base on a  square  plinth.
                    fruhhellenistischer
              84
   11   12   13   14   15   16   17   18   19   20   21