Page 39 - EW FEB 2022
P. 39

the country’s estimated                                                  schools has dangerous con-
             400,000 BPS which claim                                                  sequences. On July 29, 2021
             to offer Inglish-medium                                                  while driving to his office
             education, are the natural                                               in the afternoon, he was at-
             option of lower middle and                                               tacked by machete-wielding
             working class households                                                 goons. But when he pulled
             determined to provide                                                    out his licensed revolver and
             their children socio-eco-                                                fired in the air, the goons took
             nomic upward mobility.                                                   to their heels. An FIR has
             Consequently the neta-                                                   been registered and police is
             babu brotherhood and                                                     investigating.
             educracy are making every                                                  “Over the past decades,
             effort to delegitimise them                                              corruption has  struck  deep
             and force them into bank-                                                roots in the education bu-
             ruptcy and/or closure.  Shashi Kumar: dangerous activism                 reaucracy of Karnataka.
                Over the past almost 75                                               Laws, policies and regula-
             years since independence, India has   mar currently has eight writ petitions   tions governing private schools have
             legislated  thousands  of  laws,  rules   questioning the vires and validity of   been deliberately twisted for extor-
             and regulations. Yet a curious feature   several laws and government regula-  tion and bribery. Right from registra-
             of most of this legislation is that it is   tions and notifications pending in the   tion which requires clearance from
             not applicable to the country’s gov-  Supreme Court. Nor is this cranky,   the land revenue, fire safety and PWD
             ernment schools. A classic instance is   frivolous litigation. In 2013, he won   departments and completion of over
             provided by s.19 (1) of the landmark   a famous victory when the Supreme   two dozen documents to be stamped
             RTE Act, 2009. This section pre-  Court struck down a notification is-  and notarized, private school promot-
             scribes minimum infrastructure pro-  sued in 1994 which made Kannada the   ers have to pay bribes at every stage of
             vision including teacher-pupil-ratio,   compulsory medium of primary edu-  the process. After registration, recog-
             classroom capacity, minimum size of   cation in all schools statewide. This   nition is required by exam boards and
             kitchen  for  making  mid-day  meals,   notification which enabled education   local government. Moreover as against
             storage space for cooking material,   ministry officials to “earn millions for   five years earlier, currently recogni-
             number of toilets and a mandatory   over two decades” for turning a blind   tion or NOC (no objection certificate)
             playing field for private schools as   eye to English-medium schools openly   has to be renewed every year. Con-
             detailed in an elaborate Schedule of   violating this diktat, was struck down   sequently, promotion of greenfield
             the Act, on pain of heavy monetary   following a 19-year battle after the   private schools has been choked, with
             fines and forced closure. However,   apex court held that parents — rather   admissions into reputed top-ranked
             the country’s 1.20 million government   than the State — are best qualified to   schools breeding further corruption,”
             schools with an aggregate enrolment   choose the medium of instruction of   laments Shashi Kumar.
             of 132  million children are exempt   their children (see https://www.edu-
             from the provisions of s.19 and the   cationworld.in/karnataka-too-little-  4  TEACHER APPOINTMENTS IN
             Schedule. Yet there’s hardly a squeak   too-late/).                    GOVERNMENT SCHOOLS
             from left-liberal intellectuals about   Shashi Kumar’s determined ac-  lthough children’s learning out-
             this glaring injustice.          tivism to clean the augean stables of  Acomes in government — spe-
                One of the country’s most coura-  K-12 education in Karnataka where   cifically state and local government
             geous and indefatigable crusaders   every well-intentioned law, rule and   schools that constitute 99 percent of
             against official corruption which is   regulation has been transformed into   the country’s 1.2 million government
             “destroying education day-by-day   an opportunity to shake down private   schools — compare unfavourably with
             and blighting the future of hundreds                              private schools (as repeatedly high-
             of millions of children” is D. Shashi   The neta-babu brotherhood   lighted in the annual ASER surveys
             Kumar,  general  secretary  of  the                               of the Pratham Education Founda-
             Karnataka Associated Managements   and educracy are making        tion), government school teachers' pay
             of English Medium Schools (KAMS),   every effort to delegitimise   packages (determined by the Central
             a representative association of 4,000                             government Pay Commissions) tend
             mostly affordable private schools in   budget private schools and   to be several multiples of teachers
             Karnataka (pop.63 million). Also pro-  force them into bankruptcy   in private schools, especially budget
             moter-director of Blossoms School, a                              private schools. Therefore in a low-
             model BPS in Bengaluru, Shashi Ku-  and/or closure                growth economy where the number

                                                                             FEBRUARY 2022    EDUCATIONWORLD   39
   34   35   36   37   38   39   40   41   42   43   44