Page 14 - EW May 2023_Neat
P. 14

Mailbox




                                          doubt the managements of the Top 3   schools are denied the privilege of
                                          colleges and universities are bound   school-based teacher recruitment
                                          to have positive reactions. But given   which private schools enjoy.
                                          that print space is precious, perhaps   The centralised teacher recruit-
                                          you could consider highlighting 5   ment and transfers system for gov-
                                          USPs of these stellar educational   ernment schools invests tremendous
                                          institutions to enable school-leavers   power in the hands of bureaucrats
                                          and graduate students to make in-  and politicians which they will never
                                          formed higher education decisions.  give up. The many teacher recruit-
                                                           Himanshu Jain   ment scams that surface with mo-
                                                                 MUMBAI    notonous regularity are more than
                                                                           enough proof that this system needs
                                          For this they need to study parame-  to be replaced, and fast.
                                          ter scores in the league tables which                Mitali Basu
                                          are presented in detail — Editor                       KOLKATA

                   APRIL 2023
                                          Gritty young achiever            Corruption sword
                                          THANKS FOR highlighting the      THE DELHI EDUCATION News re-
         GDCW pride                       achievements of promising sailor   port ‘No let up in education reform’
         I WAS DELIGHTED to learn that my   Preethi Kongara in your Young   (EW April) seems to side-step the
         alma mater — Government Degree   Achiever section (EW April).     fact that several AAP leaders are fac-
         College for Women, Begumpet, Hy-   Her story of grit and determina-  ing allegations of corruption.
         derabad — is ranked among India’s   tion against all odds is inspiring. It’s   First, Manish Sisodia and now
         Top 3 government autonomous col-  heartening to read that she greatly   chief minister Arvind Kejriwal are
         leges in the EW India Higher Educa-  values the importance of education   under the CBI scanner for allegedly
         tion Rankings 2023-24 (EW April).   for success in life. Wishing her a sea   favouring liquor traders. If these
           Congratulations to principal Dr.   of opportunities!            allegations are true, it won’t be long
         Padmavathi, faculty and students                  Kannagi Maria   before corruption creeps into the
         for continuing the GDCW tradition                       CHENNAI   much-hyped Delhi school education
         of empowering women with quality                                  model as well.
         higher education.                                                                  Cinthya Anand
           I was also pleasantly surprised   Important omission                                 NEW DELHI
         to discover from the distinguished   I WISH TO draw your attention to
         alumni information provided on the   the misrepresentation of India’s map
         college website, that many alumnae   in your magazine (EW April). Al-  Time to reboot NAAC!
         have taken up teaching as a profes-  though you have taken the trouble of   RE YOUR EDITORIAL ‘Time to end
         sion. Kudos to them for taking up   including the Andaman and Nicobar   higher ed infantilisation’ (EW April),
         the challenge of educating the next   Islands this time, you have failed to   the resignation of NAAC chairperson
         generation!                      include the Union territory of Lak-  Bhushan Patwardhan has indeed
                   Renuka Reddy on EMAIL      shadweep. However small this region   opened up a can of worms. Patward-
                                          is, it belongs to the Indian Union.  han’s allegations of “malpractices”
                                            Let’s get our geography right!  at NAAC, call for not just urgent
         USPs suggestion                                   Madhavan Iyer   introspection but also immediate
         CONGRATULATIONS FOR publish-                         KOZHIKODE    action. Several mediocre colleges
         ing the comprehensive EW India                                    and universities have been awarded
         Higher Education Rankings 2023-24   Sorry — Editor                highest NAAC grades. Many gullible
         (EW April). At a time when UGC has                                students and parents get taken by
         allowed foreign universities to set up                            high NAAC grades and make their
         campuses in India, the country’s best   Flawed recruitment system  admission decisions.
         higher education institutions need to   IN THE INSIGHTFUL Expert Com-  The Union education ministry
         be acknowledged and celebrated.   ment essay ‘Transfer sword over   needs to protect the interests of
           However as a well-wisher, I have   government school teachers’ (EW   students and immediately initiate a
         a suggestion for conducting your in-  April), Prof. Krishna Kumar has   thorough clean-up and reboot NAAC.
         terviews more innovatively. Without   rightly questioned why government   Bablu Srivastava on EMAIL

         14    EDUCATIONWORLD   MAY 2023
   9   10   11   12   13   14   15   16   17   18   19