Page 25 - DISSERTATION AND THESIS HANDBOOK 2017 -2020

PROPOSAL REVIEW COMMITTEE
Dissertation Proposal Evaluation Summary Sheet Sample

Student candidate: Reviewer:

Grading Scale: E = Excellent; S = Satisfactory; U = Unsatisfactory; ?? = Cannot be determined from the
information given; NA – Not Applicable.
Global Rating: Clearly Acceptable. Needs further discussion

Criteria Rating Comments

E S U ?? NA
Statement of the
Problem (or purpose
Research Questions (or
hypothesis)

Research Design/
Paradigm
Sample Population, or
participants

Description of
researcher’s role
Instrumentation and
materials
Data collection
procedures

Timeline

Attention to ethical
issues

Limitations to the study

Writing quality

Grammar and spelling

Overall impression/
coherence
Scope (or breadth) of
the study

Feasibility of the study

25