Page 14 - MIN JUS 10 SEPT 2015

U.S. NEWS A7
Thursday 10 September

Fears of ‘Guantanamo north’ amid search for prison sites

BEN FOX the most vocal advocates now the detainee popu- down is, ‘What do you think any gains would be under-
Associated Press for shuttering the prison are lation appears to have is going to happen?’” said mined by maintaining a
MIAMI (AP) — Attorney concerned that closure bogged down as authori- Farah, who has been trying policy of indefinite deten-
Omar Farah met with three will simply mean creating ties wrestle with what to do to persuade a court to or- tion.
clients last month at the a “Guantanamo north,” with those who cannot eas- der Ba Odah’s immediate “No one would think that
prison on the U.S. Navy moving detainees to a less ily be brought to trial but release. “It’s very unnerving is a fulfillment of his pledge
base at Guantanamo Bay, high-profile location, while are considered too dan- for them.” to close Guantanamo,”
Cuba, and each worriedly continuing to hold them in- gerous to free, and others Expected to be submitted Roth said. “It would just be
asked a version of the same definitely. who have been cleared for soon to Congress, the ad- a transfer of the problem.”
ministration’s closure plan Of the 116 prisoners re-
Military personnel stand inside the brand new Camp 6 maximum security jail on the Guantanamo will include a request to lift maining at Guantanamo,
Bay U.S. Naval Base in Cuba. Expected to be submitted soon to Congress, the U.S. administration’s a ban on transferring de- 52 have been cleared for
closure plan for the prison will include a request to lift a ban on transferring detainees to the U.S. tainees to the U.S. Officials release. But most of those
Officials have not disclosed details, but the Defense Department has scouted potential prison sites have not disclosed details, are from Yemen, which
in Kansas, South Carolina and elsewhere. but the Defense Depart- Washington considers too
ment has scouted potential unstable to send prisoners.
(AP Photo/Brennan Linsley) prison sites in Kansas, South Resettling detainees in third
Carolina and elsewhere. countries has been tricky, in
question: Are we going to “Guantanamo is a symbol release but can’t be sent to Myles Caggins, a spokes- part because the defense
the United States? of injustice because many their home countries. man for the National Secu- secretary has been slow to
President Barack Obama of the men there have Farah’s clients fall into the rity Council, said the presi- give final security assuranc-
will soon present a new been imprisoned without latter category: All three dent still has “a steadfast es required by Congress.
plan to close the Guanta- charge or trial for more have been approved for commitment to closing the The last to leave were six
namo detention center in than a decade,” said Ja- release since at least 2009, Guantanamo detention fa- Yemenis sent to Oman in
an attempt to finally fulfill a meel Jaffer, deputy legal including Tariq Ba Odah, cility.” June in a deal that had
pledge made the first day director of the American who has dropped to 74 But others have made it been a year in the making.
of his first term in office, and Civil Liberties Union. “Mov- pounds because of an on- clear closure will not mean The remaining 64 include
remove what many consid- ing the men to a prison in going hunger strike. All they a halt to open-ended de- some in various stages of
er a stain on the country’s the United States won’t want after 13 years of con- tention. prosecution, such as five
human rights record. address this injustice; it will finement is to get out, not Defense Secretary Ash facing a long-stalled trial
But with the administration just create a new Guanta- to be sent to a different Carter said recently that by military commission for
evaluating possible sites to namo in place of the old lockup in the United States. about half the prisoners alleged roles in orchestrat-
hold Guantanamo inmates one.” “One of the first questions “are not safe to release, ing the Sept. 11, 2001, ter-
in the United States, even Meanwhile an effort to win- they asked when we sat period.” rorist attacks. Prosecutors
“Some of the people who say relatively few could
are there at Guantanamo be tried for war crimes by
Bay have to be detained military commissions, and
indefinitely, OK? They just could only be charged if
got to be locked up,” sent to U.S. civilian courts.
Carter said. “So if they’re Thirty-two are under a “law
not locked up in Guanta- of war detention” desig-
namo Bay, they need to be nation, meaning the U.S.
locked up somewhere.” doesn’t have evidence to
Opponents of the Gitmo charge them but asserts
detention center say the the right to detain them
U.S. should try to prosecute until the end of hostilities.
whomever they can and The uncertain nature of the
release the rest. terror conflict means they
A transfer stateside could could theoretically be held
result in some benefits for forever.
prisoners, such as easier Roth said officials fear the
access to lawyers and per- political consequences if
haps the first visits by fam- released detainees were to
ily members. But Kenneth attack the U.S. in the future,
Roth, executive director of but argued that the risk is
Human Rights Watch, said overstated.q