Page 2 - ATD20MAR2023
P. 2

A2   UP FRONT
                     Monday 20 March 2023
            Higher cancer rates found in military pilots, ground crews




            Continued from Front         The Pentagon said  the  Fighter Pilots  Association,
                                         new study was  one of the  which had lobbied the
            The study  showed ground  largest and most compre-        Pentagon and  Congress
            crews  had a 19% higher  hensive to date. An earlier  for help. Alcazar serves on
            rate of brain  and  nervous  study  had  looked at just  the association’s  medical
            system  cancers, a 15%  Air Force  pilots  and had  issues committee.
            higher rate of thyroid can-  found some  higher rates  The study was required by
            cer  and a 9% higher  rate  of cancer, while this one  Congress in the 2021  de-
            of kidney or renal cancers,  looked  across all services  fense bill. Now, because
            while women  had a 7%  and at both air and ground  higher  rates were found,
            higher rate of  breast  can-  crews. Even with the wider  the Pentagon must con-
            cer. The overall  rate for  approach, the Pentagon  duct an even bigger re-
            cancers of all types was 3%  cautioned that the actual  view  to try to understand
            higher.                      number of cancer cases  why the crews are getting
            There was  some good  was likely to be even high-         sick.
            news reported as well. Both  er because of gaps in the  Isolating potential causes is
            ground and air crews had  data, which it said it would  difficult, and the Pentagon
            far lower rates of lung can-  work to remedy.             was careful to note  that
            cer, and air crews also had  The study “proves that it’s  this  study  “does not imply
            lower rates of bladder and  well past time for  leaders  that  military service in air
            colon cancers.               and policy makers to move  crew or ground  crew oc-
            The data compared the  from skepticism  to belief  cupations causes cancer,
            service members with the  and active assistance,”  because  there are multi-
            general U.S. population af-  said  retired Air Force Col.  ple  potential confounding
            ter adjusting  for age, sex  Vince Alcazar,  a member  factors that could  not be
            and race.                    of the Red River Valley  controlled for in this analy-











                                                                                                   This image provided by Betty Seaman shows Navy A-6 Intruder
                                                                                                   pilot Jim Seaman. Navy Capt. Jim Seaman died of lung cancer
                                                                                                   at the age of 61.
                                                                                                                                            Associated Press
                                                                                                   sis,” such as family histories,  finally seeing in data what
                                                                                                   smoking or alcohol use.      they  have suspected for
                                                                                                   But aviation  crews have  years about the aviation
                                                                                                   long asked for the Penta-    cancers. But “it has the po-
                                                                                                   gon to look closely at some  tential to do a lot of good
                                                                                                   of the environmental  fac-   as far as early communica-
                                                                                                   tors they are exposed to,  tion, early  detection,” she
                                                                                                   such as jet fuels and sol-   said.
                                                                                                   vents used to  clean and  The study found that when
                                                                                                   maintain jet parts, sensors  crew members were di-
                                                                                                   and their power sources in  agnosed     with   cancer,
                                                                                                   aircraft nose cones, and  they were more  likely  to
                                                                                                   the massive  radar systems  survive than  members of
                                                                                                   on the decks of the ships  the general population,
                                                                                                   they land on.                which the study suggested
                                                                                                   When Navy Capt. Jim Sea-     was  because they were
                                                                                                   man would come home  diagnosed earlier due to
                                                                                                   from a deployment aboard  regular required medical
                                                                                                   an aircraft carrier, his gear  checkups and were more
                                                                                                   would reek  of jet fuel, his  likely to be in better health
                                                                                                   widow Betty Seaman said.  because of their military fit-
                                                                                                   The A-6 Intruder pilot died  ness requirements.
                                                                                                   in  2018  at age 61  of lung  The Pentagon  acknowl-
                                                                                                   cancer.                      edged that the study had
                                                                                                   Betty Seaman still  has his  gaps that likely led to an
                                                                                                   gear stored and it still smells  undercount of cancer cas-
                                                                                                   of fuel, “which I love,” she  es.
                                                                                                   said.                        The military  heath system
                                                                                                   She and others  wonder  database used in the study
                                                                                                   if there’s a link. She said  did not have reliable can-
                                                                                                   crews would talk about  cer data until  1990,  so it
                                                                                                   how even the ship’s water  may  not have included
                                                                                                   systems would smell of fuel.  pilots  who  flew  early-gen-
                                                                                                   She said  she and others  eration jets  in  the prior
                                                                                                   have mixed feelings about  decades.q
   1   2   3   4   5   6   7