Page 168 - 20780
P. 168
168 | A New Light Chapter Six: | 185
means that heaven is not pleased with a person’s work, because prayed and was answered, and the other prayed and was
he is not doing what is required of him. Therefore, heaven sends not answered. Why was one answered and the other not
him sufferings in various areas of his life in order to awaken him. answered? One prayed with a perfect prayer, and he was
But when he works on one goal in a fundamental manner, there is answered. The other did not pray with a perfect prayer,
no judgment against him—even though he sets aside other worthy and he was not answered.
goals—because heaven knows that he has a great deal to rectify,
and he cannot rectify everything at once. Heaven is happy that We would all like to know the great secret: what does having 6
he has chosen one area to rectify, and heaven is patient with him our prayers answered depend on? All of us pray and all of us want
regarding all of the other issues that he is not working on. But to see results from our prayers. Is there a way of praying that is
if a person does not choose one issue to work on, heaven sees guaranteed to work and that will be accepted in every situation?
that he will never actually rectify anything. Therefore, it sends him The Gemara reports that the sages already answered this question.
suffering in order to awaken him. Thus, when a person engages in Rabbi Meir tells about two people who were seriously ill. They both
fundamental work on one issue, that shields and guards him, and had the exact same illness to the exact same extent, and they both
sweetens all of the judgments against him. prayed. One was healed, and the other passed away. Rabbi Meir
also tells about two defendants (in a gentile court) accused of the
No normal father expects his son to do things that are beyond his same capital offense. Both prayed. One was acquitted and set free,
abilities and powers. Similarly, Hashem does not unfairly demand and the other was convicted and executed. Rabbi Meir’s intent is
that a person must work on all of his issues immediately, because to explain the difference. Certainly, they all sensed the great danger
that is not in his power. When a normal father sees that his son is they were in, as though a sharp sword was hanging over their necks,
applying himself as best he can, he has no complaints about his son— and certainly they all wanted to live. It was clear that they had no
on the contrary, he is very pleased with him. So too the Holy One, alternative but one counsel only: to pray. They all believed that
blessed be He, is very pleased with everyone who applies himself as Hashem, only Hashem, could help them, and so they all prayed to
best he can. He has no complaints against him, no accusations and Him. That being the case, it is hard to understand why one of each
no judgment. If the trait of judgment will argue that this person is pair was saved and the other was not saved.
not doing so-and-so, immediately it will be rebuked, “What do you
want from him? Overall, he is working and progressing regarding The Gemara and the commentaries explain that Rabbi Meir
such-and-such an issue. With time, he will achieve success, and then presumes that the heavenly court had already decreed and sealed
he will go on to work on mastering other areas in his life.” When the judgment of death against all four men. Nevertheless, for two
a person has no judgments against him, his life is good and sweet. of them prayer helped and nullified the decree, but for the other
two it did not help. Why? Rabbi Meir answers that the two who
Patience were saved prayed a perfect prayer, whereas the two who died
did not. Rashi explains succinctly that “a perfect prayer” means
We must review and recall this simple truth: It is impossible to “having intent.” When I learned this Gemara, I was very puzzled.
rectify everything at once. The evil inclination loves to make a What does it mean that the two who died lacked intent? Didn’t
person forget this simple truth in order to torment and break him. they want to live? I thought a very great deal about the words of
But we must know this most important principle regarding all of a the Gemara. Certainly, they wanted to live. So why was one of
person’s work in this world. each pair answered and the other not? I made a few conjectures,
but none of them satisfied me and seemed adequate. I did not feel
The Holy One, blessed be He, made man finite, and it is His will