Page 16 - article
P. 16

FOCUS ARTICLE


                                                                        unnoticed is Narendra Modi’s visit to
                                                                        Israel last year, the first by an Indian
                                                                        PM, was not accompanied by a visit
                                                                        to  Palestine. Despite India’s voting
           India’s Vote on Jerusalem                                    pattern  in  the  UN  Human  Rights
                                                                        Council earlier this year, where it voted
                                                                        against  Israel  on  four  out  of  five
       The Jerusalem vote sends New Delhi’s clear signals that it has the credential to  resolutions and abstained on one, there
       be counted as a global player no matter what the US views on international  has been a perception in some quarters
                                                                        that the BJP government has started
       issues are                             —By  Pallab  Bhattacharya
                                                                        viewing Palestine through the prism of
                                                                        majoritarian politics at home.
       When India went with the overwhelming  imports annually is too important for  UNGA VOTE SUGGESTS BONHOMIE
       majority of UN member-countries and  India not to antagonize the Arab world.  So,  New  Delhi’s  UNGA  vote  is  a
       voted  against  the  United  States’  So is the security of millions of Indians  reassurance  that  India  sticks  to its
       decision to declare Jerusalem as the  in West Asia. According to the World  principled  and  its  long-held  policy
       capital of Israel, it elicited a range of  Bank estimate, about 7 million Indian  favouring a negotiated settlement on
       interpretations as to the direction of  nationals  working  in  the  three  Gulf  the question of Jerusalem as part of a
       New Delhi’s policy towards the Middle  countries of Saudi Arabia, UAE and  larger intractable two-state solution for
       East and West Asian cauldron.                                    Israel and Palestine. During his Israel
       HISTORIC DECISION BY INDIA                                       visit, Modi did not specify the broad
       On  December  21,  the  tenth United      In Brief               outlines of such settlement nor was he
       Nations  General  Assembly  (UNGA)   India voted against the US’  expected to for the simple reason is
       special session was reconvened at the  decision to declare Jerusalem  that India is not yet a key player in the
       request of the  Arab  Group  and  the  as the capital of Israel.  Middle East even  though peace and
       Organization of Islamic  Cooperation                             stability  there  is  of  paramount
       to consider the issue and the House   The  resolution  moved  in  importance  for  millions  of  Indians
       voted 128 to 9 to oppose any attempt  UNGA    on   Jerusalem     working or settled in West Asia. After
       by the  United States  to  change the  effectively  condemns  the  Israel occupied East Jerusalem in the
       status  quo  on  Jerusalem.  The     unilateral US move.         1967  war,  both  UNGA  and  UN
       resolution  moved  in  UNGA  on    The vote against the US on   Security Council affirmed that Israel’s
       Jerusalem  effectively condemns the  Jerusalem  is  not  the  first  “acquisition  of  territory  by  war”  is
       unilateral  US  move  and  calls  for  instance in recent past of New  inadmissible  and  called  for  the
       compliance  with  Security  Council  Delhi’s such actions.       withdrawal of Israeli armed forces from
       resolutions  on the  status of the city   India had supported a move  occupied territories,  including  East
       which is also claimed by Palestine as  by  Mauritius  to  assert  its  Jerusalem. The UNSC resolution 476,
       its capital. Most of the countries also  sovereignty  over  Chagos  adopted  in  1980,  reiterated  the
       views  East  Jerusalem  as  a  part  of                          illegality of any move to alter the status
       Palestine.                           Archipelago  controlled  by  of Jerusalem, and asked all countries
          The Indian vote came days  after  Britain.                    “that  have  established  diplomatic
       New  Delhi-based  envoys  of  Arab   It sends clear signals that New  missions at Jerusalem to close such
       countries in a coordinated move met  Delhi has the credential to be  missions  from  the  city.  India  has
       the Ministry of External Affairs officials  counted as a global player.  endorsed the position of UNGA and
       and were forthright in expressing their                          UNSC on Jerusalem.
       worry to Minister of State for External                            On the other hand, India’s relations,
       Affairs M.J. Akbar over New Delhi’s  Qatar, which were visited by Modi in  especially defence and economic, with
       stand. After that, the MEA went public  2015  and  2016,  remitted  US$28.2  Israel has been on a sustained upswing
       with a cryptic statement that India’s  billion to India’s household economy  since  the  diplomatic  ties  were
       stance will be rooted in its own “views  in 2015. The UAE Ambassador to India  established in 1991 under Congress
       and interests (and) not determined by  had announced that the US$75 billion  rule in India when PV Narasimha Rao
       any third country”.             sovereign wealth fund for  India had  was Prime Minister. That subsequently
          These  national  interests  are  been  opened  up  with  US$1  billion  the BJP dispensations took the ties
       increasingly  reflected  in  India’s  already transferred to India’s National  with  Israel  forward only  reflects the
       stepped-up engagement with its Arab  Infrastructure and Investment Fund.  bipartisan domestic  support in India
       and Persian Gulf countries. Oil and gas  Clearly, the concerns in the Arab  in close relations with that country.
       supplies from West Asian accounting  world  have increased as India-Israel  India’s vote on Jerusalem issue has
       for  almost  60%  of  India’s  energy  ties have improved. What has not gone  been  viewed  by  some  analysts  as
       March 2018                                                                  Competition  Wizard  39
   11   12   13   14   15   16   17   18   19   20   21