Page 211 - The Errors the American National Academy of Sciences
P. 211

The NAS's Human Evolution Error



                 whether    or   not    "moderns"    and
                 "Neandertals" were different species.  23
                 Karl J. Niklas of Cornell University
            refers to the use of the concept
            of the molecular

            clock to establish
            relationships be-
            tween species as
            "…A research area that is
            at present characterized by too
            much speculation chasing too few
            data."  24
                 An article published in
            Science in 1998 said that the molecular

            clock could be in error by as much as twenty-fold.
            Neil Howard of the University of Texas Medical Branch says,
                 We've been treating this like a stop-watch, and I'm concerned that
                 it's as precise as a sun dial.  25


                 3. Problems regarding the use of mtDNA in the establishment

                 of evolutionary relationships

                 Even evolutionists debate amongst themselves whether the use
            of mtDNA to determine evolutionary relationships is an accurate
            method. The Stanford University geneticist Luca Cavalli-Sforza and
            his associates write:
                 [T]he mitochondrial genome represents only a small fraction of an
                 individual's genetic material and may not be representative of the
                 whole. 26

                 After testing the assumptions underlying the use of mtDNA to






                                            209
   206   207   208   209   210   211   212   213   214   215   216