Page 27 - Lungshan Pottery Lunshanoid Research 1977 Paper
P. 27

1 9








                     teristics     of each     different     classification.          Only when

                     classificatory       problems are       fully resolved,        will    archaeo-

                     logy   be  able   to reach     the   realm of     science.



                            Nevertheless,       the reason for        this   difficulty      in

                     classification        (or arrangement)        is also that       archaeologists

                     are   easily    led into     subjectivity      when making decisions

                     on  classification.         Most archaeologists           are  aware of      the

                     problem.      A.C.   Spaulding s       "Statistical Techniques           for
                                                        1
                     the  Discovery      of  Artifact     Types"    clearly     illustrates

                     this   point.     In   this   article,     he  states that       i f  artifact

                     types   really    do   exist,    then they can       be  discovered       by

                     statistical      methods     ( 1 9 5 3 *  3 0 5 ) .


                            In  order    to  gain some knowledge of the             use   of   classi-

                     fication     in Chinese archaeology, I have selected                   a number

                     of examples dealing with            both   artifacts      and  larger     cultural

                     units.     L i Chi^s    Hsiao-t*un.       vol.   I l l ,  Fascicle I, part       I,

                     was  the   first    work done.       In   this   work, the     author     tried

                     to use   !a consistent       format for organizing          the material       from

                     one   site.



                            The   primary scheme used          by  L i Chi   ( 1 9 5 6 *  3 6 - 3 7 )  in

                     his   classification       of pottery      vessels     from Hsiao-Vun         is

                     as   followsi
   22   23   24   25   26   27   28   29   30   31   32