Page 479 - Wordsmith A Guide to College Writing
P. 479
Logos (low-gahse or low-gohse), or logic, according to Aristotle, is the
final element in argument or persuasion. The Greek word logos is at
the root of English words such as logic and logical. Logic is extremely
important in making an argument or persuading an audience. No
matter how strong the other elements of your writing are, they will
count for nothing if your argument does not make sense.
Signs of Flawed Logic in Argument
Here are some danger signs that may signal flawed logic:
Painting with too broad a brush. If you say “Older people are
usually bad drivers because their reflexes have slowed and their
reaction time is poor,” you are generalizing, or painting an entire group
of people with a single brushstroke. On the one hand, words such as
usually, never, and always increase your responsibility to make sure
that what you are saying is absolutely accurate. On the other hand,
words such as often, can, and may allow you to make a point without
using too broad a brush. Saying “Older drivers may lose their ability to
react quickly as they age” is much more realistic.
Staying on the surface. If you find yourself repeating generalizations
instead of analyzing, providing strong support, and giving examples,
your argument is a surface argument.
Making exaggerated claims. Have you seen ads that make claims
like this?