Page 84 - Makino,Tsutusi.DictionaryOfIntermediateJGrammar
P. 84

10  - bakari ka - (sae)








            I.  The phrases bakari de (wa) naku - (mo) and dake de (wa) naku - (mo)
               are very  similar to bakari ka  - (sae). Among those three constructions
               bakari  ka  -  (sae)  expresses  the  highest  degree  of  unexpectedness
               between the content of S, and Sz. If such unexpectedness is missing, the
               bakari ka  - (sae) construction  sounds awkward. Examples follow.

                 [1]  a.  &a>Ad&.B5& {EIf /lifi>bGl] T(lb)Q<x;l."-';r&d:{
                        &&ao
                        (He is  not  only  good  scholastically;  he  is  also  good  at
                        sports.)








                     b.  ??zo$l&.~~b'lifi'~Ih'f~tbC:Sx~&,
                               (+ dake de (wa) naku - (mo) (DBJG: 97-100))

            11.  S1 dokoroka Sz, a construction indicating that s.0. / s.t. is very far from
               ah (un)desirable state, is quite different from SI bakari ka SZ, when S1 is
               affirmative and Sz is negative or when S1 is negative and S2 is affirma-
               tive. Examples follow.
                                                       bit,  k'
                 [3]  %&.EI$z~'s*& {ZL3fi' /*lffi>blfi>l, -E&BS&Lf:L
                     275'69 ash,
                     (I am far from being able to speak Japanese; I haven't  studied it
                     at all.)
   79   80   81   82   83   84   85   86   87   88   89