Page 271 - BSN_COPC_v1

CAGAYAN STATE UNIVERSITY 13
MC4 Logic and Critical Thinking

RUBRIC FOR ASSESSMENT TO BE USED FOR Case Study Presentation (15% of final grade)

Excellent Good Satisfactory
Criteria Score
15 pts 10 pts 5 pt
Content Clarity The case study is exceptionally clear, The case study is clear, concise, and The case study lacks clarity,
and Relevance concise, and relevant. It effectively relevant. It adequately presents conciseness, or relevance in some
presents background information, key background information, key issues, and aspects. Some background information,
issues, and proposed solutions. proposed solutions. key issues, or proposed solutions are
unclear or incomplete.

Logical The case study demonstrates thorough The case study demonstrates adequate The case study demonstrates limited
Reasoning and logical reasoning and critical analysis. logical reasoning and critical analysis. logical reasoning and critical analysis.
Critical Analysis Arguments are well-supported with Arguments are supported with evidence, Arguments may lack support or contain
evidence, and logical fallacies are but there may be some minor logical noticeable logical fallacies.
avoided. fallacies present.

Creativity and The case study demonstrates The case study demonstrates creativity The case study demonstrates some
Originality exceptional creativity and originality. It and originality. It presents an interesting creativity and originality, but the scenario
presents a unique and thought-provoking scenario that captures the audience's may be somewhat predictable or
scenario that engages the audience. attention. uninspired.
Presentation The presentation is exceptionally clear, The presentation is clear, organized, and The presentation is somewhat unclear,
Delivery organized, and engaging. Speakers engaging. Speakers communicate disorganized, or lacks engagement.
communicate effectively, maintain eye effectively but may occasionally lack eye Speakers may struggle to communicate
contact, and use appropriate gestures contact or use of appropriate gestures effectively, maintain eye contact, or use
and visual aids. and visual aids. appropriate gestures and visual aids.

Time The presentation is well-paced and The presentation is mostly well-paced The presentation is somewhat rushed or
Management adheres to the time limit. All key points and adheres to the time limit. Most key too lengthy. Some key points may be
are covered thoroughly within the points are covered within the allocated omitted or only briefly discussed due to
allocated time. time, with minor deviations. time constraints.

Total Score

Legend 51-75 Excellent 26-50 Good 25 Satisfactory

F-ODI-2056
Revision No. 07 January 31, 2024