Page 62 - EW JULY PDF
P. 62

Books



         Unsung                      INDIA'S TIPPING POINT                         continued to be prac-
                                                                                   ticed by his daughter and
         economy                     S. Narendra                                   four-times prime minister
                                                                                   Indira Gandhi, her son
         gamechanger                 Bloomsbury India                              Rajiv and is now being
                                     Rs.699
                                     212 pp                                        preached by her grand-
                                                                                   son Rahul. Consequently,
               URING THE past                                                      the Indian economy was
               76 years since India                                                stuck in the 3.5 percent
         Dwrested freedom                                                          annual GDP growth rate
         from almost 200 years of   enterprise and perpetu-  In this biography,    for over 40 years, even as
         British rule, P.V. Nara-  ated poverty and illiteracy   the author details   our neighbour South-east
         simha Rao (PVNR, 1921-   in post-independence      how prime minister     Asian economies grew by
         2004) was undoubtedly    India, has been ignored   Narasimha Rao          6-7 percent, and China
         the greatest of India’s 14   by the media and media   unshackled the Indian   by 10 percent year-on-
         prime ministers. Although   pundits. The plain truth is   economy by stealth  year after Deng Xioping
         he served only one term   that India’s 400-million-                       liberalised the Chinese
         in office (1991-96), during   strong middle class with                    economy in 1978 and fa-
         those momentous years    deep connections — uncle,   Rajiv Gandhi’s assassina-  mously declared “to be rich
         he substantially won the   brother, nephew — pros-  tion in 1991, Rao had been   is glorious”.
         country’s economic free-  pering within the brother-  appointed PM with the   Although obliged to
         dom by pulling it out of the   hood, isn’t dissatisfied with   tacit sanction of his widow   maintain a low profile as
         mire of neta-babu social-  licence raj. It provides hid-  Sonia Gandhi, whose   minister in Mrs. Gan-
         ism which had sentenced   den subsidies — inflation-  expectation was that as a   dhi’s and Rajiv’s cabinet,
         it to a rock-bottom 3.5   proof salaries, subsidised   former minister in Rajiv’s   there’s no doubt that Rao
         percent GDP growth per   electricity, water, higher   cabinet he would be a   — an arts/law graduate
         year for four decades after   education, pensions — and   pliable caretaker PM and   of Osmania and Bombay
         independence, and wiped   keeps private businessmen   toe the socialist line. But   universities — was erudite.
         out the modest material   (baniyas) in check.     this calculation went awry   He had learnt 17 languages
         aspirations of an entire   Highly risk-averse,    because unlike all previous   and was well aware of the
         generation of free India’s   under the influence of Ne-  prime ministers, Rao was   amazing progress of the
         children.                hruvian socialism nothing   genuinely educated.   Tiger economies of Asia
            This informative biogra-  gets the middle class goat   Jawaharlal, the only   and China in particular, as
         phy written by S. Naren-  more than businessmen   Nehru to earn a university   also of new media in India
         dra, who as a senior aide of   prospering and flaunting   degree, scraped through   which routinely trashed
         PVNR and principal infor-  their money. Which is why   with a third class de-  licence raj and proclaimed
         mation officer and adviser   even three decades after   gree in natural sciences   success stories of private
         to the Union government   liberalisation, Congress   at Cambridge and was   enterprises (Business In-
         (1992-98), had a ringside   leader Rahul Gandhi of the   totally economics illiterate.   dia, BusinessWorld).
         view of those tumultuous   Nehru dynasty continues   However that didn’t stop   Therefore, one of his
         years during which the   to excoriate India’s most   him from upturning the   first initiatives after he
         choke-hold of the neta-ba-  successful entrepreneurs   Indian economy which had   became prime minister
         bu brotherhood on India’s   — Ambani-Adani — who   a thousand year tradition   of politically free, but
         economy was substantially   have risen from rags to   of free enterprise, and con-  economically enslaved
         broken, was overdue. It’s   riches for ‘corruption’, i.e,   verting it into a “socialist   India, was to abolish the
         a measure of the extent   transgression of absurd   pattern of society”. Central   Industries (Development
         to which the establish-  economic laws enacted    planning meant strangling   & Regulation) Act, 1951
         ment is committed to the   by negligent Parliaments   private enterprise and   which required Central
         status quo ante, that this   down the ages.       establishing vast public   government licences to
         revealing biography which   The author details    sector enterprises (PSEs)   start industrial enterprises
         details the step-by-step   how PVNR steered and   managed by business-illit-  and bureaucrats in Delhi
         dismantling of the licence-  unshackled the Indian   erate, risk-averse bureau-  and/or the state capitals
         permit-quota regime,     economy by stealth for   crats who quickly ran them   controlled their expansion,
         which had smothered the   fear of the academy/es-  into the ground.       prices and governance.
         native spirit of private   tablishment. Following   This arid socialism     In retrospect, the

         62    EDUCATIONWORLD   JULY 2023
   57   58   59   60   61   62   63   64   65   66   67