Page 46 - WIS

APPENDIX

Self-assessment tool for Wildlife Impact Study Report quality control

Assessment criteria Score Expected
assessment result
All important tasks (e.g. wildlife study, standard eld methods, impact A The Report can be
prediction, proposed mitigation measure, wherever relevant) were approved.

performed
All TOR wildlife-components were covered Wildlife Impact Study
Report complies with the report standard format
Data and information are factually correct, can be veri ed, and
technically defensible
Wildlife Impact Study Report is coherent, legible, and balanced
Proposed mitigation measures are considered to be best practices

Most important tasks (e.g. wildlife studies, standard eld methods, A The Report can be
impact prediction, proposed mitigation measure, wherever relevant) approved.
were performed but some minor ones were not performed
All TOR wildlife-components were covered
Data are factually correct and technically defensible, but some
non-substantive facts cannot be veri ed
Wildlife Impact Study Report is coherent and balanced but some
non-substantive information may not be presented clearly
Wildlife Impact Study Report complies with the report standard format
Some non-crucial contents (e.g., scienti c name, protection status) of
Wildlife Impact Study Report are not performed or incorrect

Important tasks (e.g., wildlife studies, standard eld methods, impact F The Report cannot be
prediction, proposed mitigation measure, wherever relevant) were not approved and will be
performed rejected.
Some TOR wildlife-components were not covered
Wildlife Impact Study Report did not comply with the report standard
format
Important data and information are factually incorrect and are not
technically defensible
Important studies were not conducted, or inadequate, or technically
awed.
Some parts of Wildlife Impact Study Report are biased, incoherent, and
unreadable

Proposed mitigation measures are not considered to be best practices
The score of an A or B or F in column 2 of Table 3.2 is assigned as the
overall score of the Wildlife Impact Study Report. To achieve an overall
score A or B, all the criteria listed in column 1 of the Table must be

complied with. On the other hand, an overall F score will be given to the
Report if any of the criteria listed in column 1 is not complied with.

42 GUIDANCE DOCUMENT ON WILDLIFE
IMPACT STUDY FOR IN ENVIRONMENTAL
IMPACT ASSESSMENT (EIA)