Page 208 - INDONESIA ISLAMIC CULTURE
P. 208

side it seemed that both sides tried to   so that it suited their heretical belief   (henceforth simply called Tibyan) is   heterodox and even perverted people of   Kitab Kuning Alfiyah
 show the corrections theological belief.   system. Our response is that he   considered the most important book on   the wujudiyyah” (kaum wujudiyyah yang   Ibnu Malik written by
 Therefore, the works that have made it   or she will be called a heterodox   the deviancy of the wujudiyyah notions.   zindiq, mulhid lagi sesat). He said,   Imam Ibnu Malik, on the
 to our era may describe the wujudiyyah   unbeliever who adopts the basic   More specifically in around two-third   “At that time the heretically heterodox   grammar of Arabic
 notions merely based on al-Raniri’s   meaning of unclear verses, prophetic   of the pages of this treatise, al-Raniri   and even perverted wujudiyyah   Source: Directorate of
 version.  traditions on divine attributes and Sufi   elaborated both Hamzah Fansuri and   emerged, namely of the disciples   History and Cultural
 ecstatic utterances as arguments and   al-Sumatra’i’s misleading notions. Al-              Values, Ministry of
 In the Fath al-Mubin, for example,   Raniri himself specifically recommended   of the perverted Shamsuddin al-
 al-Raniri illustrated that among the   evidence.” 47  everyone who wanted to know in depth   Sumatra’i… they discussed with us for   Education and Culture
 issues the people of Wahdat al-Mutlaq   From this explanation in the Fath al-  the notions al-Raniri called the “beliefs   several days in the presence of the   of the Republic of
 discussed was that they based their   Mubin, it is clear that the perverted   of the perverted people” (i’tikad kaum   most pious Sultan of the era…” 50  Indonesia
 theological ideas of the wujudiyyah on   (sesat) and unbelief fatwa issued by al-  dalalah) to read his Tibyan. In the Ma
 unclear Qur’anic verses, like yad Allah   Raniri against the followers of Absolute   al-hayah li ahl al-mamat, for example,   Easing Mystic-Philosophical
 fawqa aydihim (God’s hand above their   Monism can also be related to a similarly   al-Raniri asserted ,   Thought
 hands), or on prophetic traditions about   perverted fatwa issued against previous   The socio-religious upheaval that started
 the divine attributes such as al-hajar   Sufis in the Muslim world, such as Abu   “O students, if you want to know   in Aceh during the last period of Sultan
 al-aswad yamin Allah fi al-ard (the black   Yazid al-Bistami (d. 875) who was famed   the beliefs of the perverted people,   Iskandar Thani’s reign was due to the
 stone is the right hand of God on earth),   for his doctrine of unity (ittihad) and his   you have to scrutinize and read the   dispute over the philosophical mysticism
 as well as on the ecstatic utterances of   ecstatic utterance subhani ma a’zama   Tibyan fi Ma’rifat al-Adyan that I have   in al-Tuhfah al-Mursalah. This upheaval
                   49
 some Sufis like ana al-haqq (I am [God]   sha’ni (the Glory of Me, the greatest   written.”  seemed to have been prolonged and yet
 the Real), subhani ma a’zama sha’ni   condition of me), and the notion of hulul   Al-Raniri introductory remarks in the   to have abated in the intermediate period
 (the Glory of Me, the greatest condition   by Husayn ibn Mansur al-Hallaj (m.   Tibyan’sopening part show that the   of his successor, Sultanah Safiyatuddin.
 of me), ma fi jubbati illa Allah (nothing   922), who was famous for his ecstatic   treatise was composed during the latter   This was proven by the discovery of an
 in my robe but Allah). Al-Raniri saw that   statement ana al-haqq (I am [God] the   part of Sultan Iskandar Thani’s reign   Arabic text on Sufism written around
 they had deviated in their interpretation   Real). As is known, both were accused of   (1636-1641) and the start of that of   1665 that contained a ‘report’ on the
 of the Qur’anic verses, the hadith, and   being perverted and the scholars of the   his successor, Sultanah Safiyatuddin   upheaval, the Ithaf al-Dhaki bi Sharh
 the Sufis’ ecstatic utterances which,   Shari’a of their times sentenced them to   (1641-1676). Al-Raniri wrote that during   al-Tuhfah al-Mursalah ila al-Nabi
 according to al-Raniri, all should be   death. 48  Iskandar Thani’s reign, the court was   Salla Allahu ‘Alayhi wa Sallama, or in
 understood as being symbolic and not   actively involved in the debate against   English “An offering to the skillful soul:
 considered in their literal meanings. Al-  Beside Fath al-Mubin, al-Raniri’s   al-Sumatra’i’s disciples, who were   An explanation of the book bestowed
 Raniri said,  other work Tibyan fi Ma’rifat al-Adyan   stereotypically dubbed “the heretically   upon the Prophet [Muhammad] peace
 47.  Nuruddin al-Raniri, Fath al-Mubin…, p. 3.  49.  See H.W.M.Syagir Abdullah, Khazanah Karya   50.  Nuruddin al-Raniri, Tibyan fi Ma’rifat al-Adyan,
 “…hence they changed the meaning   48.  See Simuh, Tasawuf dan Perkembangannya…,   Pusaka Asia Tenggara I (Kuala Lumpur: Khazanah   ms. no. 4209/07.1437 in the collection of Museum
 in the Jawi [read: Malay] language   139-158.  Fathaniyah, 1991), p. 53.  Negeri Aceh, fol. 2-3.



 198  Indonesian Islamic Culture in Historical Perspectives     Indonesian Islamic Culture in Historical Perspectives  199
   203   204   205   206   207   208   209   210   211   212   213