Page 19 - HaMizrachi Pesach 5782 USA
P. 19

Mirrors and Apples:




        Women’s Leadership on the Seder Plate
                                                                                                         Rabbanit
                                                                                                         Shani Taragin








      Sinks and ‘selfies’              present. The women understood that   Rabbis offer two explanations: “Why
                                       by reflecting on the past they could   is it a religious requirement? R. Levi
          nterestingly,  Sefer Shemot opens   overcome the adverse conditions of the   said: In memory of the apple tree.
          with many anonymous char-    present, and continue to increase and   R. Yochanan said: In memory of the
          acters, predominantly women,   multiply for the future! Rabbi Yesha-  clay. Abaye observed: Therefore one
      Iwho  all  share  character  traits   yahu Horowitz, the Shelah Hakadosh,   must make it acrid and then thicken
      of “seeing,” “fearing,” and saving   explains that women are consistently   it. We make it acrid in memory of the
      innocent Hebrew infants. The Rabbis   leaders of redemption because, like the   apple tree, and thicken it in memory
      explain that just as the midwives,   moon, they understand and embrace   of the clay” (Pesachim 116b). Rashbam
      Shifrah and Puah, risked their lives   the nature of mirrors and reflective   explains that the symbolic presence of
      to spare the baby boys from Pha-  light. Women appreciate that what
      raoh’s decree of infanticide, numer-  is seen in the present is in fact light   the apple in the charoset reminds us
                                                                        of the women who gave birth under
      ous righteous women planted seeds   reflected from its source, refracted
      of redemption through determination   and reversed while projected upon a   the apple trees without despair, so
      and optimism amidst the darkness   new surface. They don’t just see the   that the Egyptians would not discern
      of oppression. Rashi (Shemot 38:8)   present picture but appreciate the past   the births as stated, “under the apple
      explains that the copper mirrors   and future as well. With this deeper   tree I awakened you” (Shir Hashirim
      donated by the women to the Mishkan   perspective, the women used their   8:5). Rabbi Levi and Rabbi Yochanan
      reflect their earlier contributions to   mirrors to reflect the light of redemp-  are debating whether the  charoset
      building Jewish nationhood in Egypt:   tion and bring the sweetness of the   symbolizes the spirit of the ‘apple’
                                                                        in Egypt, i.e. the women who used
      “[Hashem said to Moshe:] ‘Accept   apple tree to our people amidst the   their mirrors to build the future of
      [these mirrors]; they are dearer to   suffering of Egypt.         our people under apple trees, or the
      Me than all the other contributions,                              spirit of the men who were ‘stuck’ in
      because through them the women   The apple on the Seder plate     the clay, i.e. the mortar and suffering
      reared those multitudes in Egypt!’ For   “Rav Avira taught: In the merit of the   of the present. If the emphasis is on
      when their husbands were exhausted                                the women’s optimism, one should
      by  the  crushing  labor  they  would   righteous women that were in that   prepare the charoset tart with more
                                       generation, the Jewish people were
      bring them food and drink and induce                              apples; if the memory of our suffering
      them to eat. Then they would take the   redeemed from Egypt.” (Sotah 11b)  is primary, the  charoset should be
      mirrors, and each gazed at herself in   The imagery of the apple trees under   thicker to resemble the clay.
      her mirror together with her husband,   which the women conceived and gave
      saying endearingly to him, ‘See, I am   birth to the multitudes of Israel is   On Seder night we dip the bitter maror
      more attractive than you!’ Thus they   an appropriate metaphor from Shir   into the sweet charoset, simultaneously
      awakened their husbands’ affection   Hashirim, in which the male persona   remembering the bitter oppressions
      and subsequently became the moth-  is depicted as an apple tree (2:3,5).   of the past and present and the joy of
      ers of many children, as it is said, ‘I   The sweetness and seeds of the apple   the apple tree – the optimism of the
      awakened your love under the apple   convey romantic love and underscore   women to procreate and plant seeds,
      tree’ (Shir Hashirim 8:5).”      symbols of demographic growth pro-  creating and catalyzing salvation, םי ִמָּי ַּ ב
                                       vided by the women.              ה ֶּז ַה ן ַמ ְּז ַבּו ם ֵה ַה, in those days and in our
      The righteous women used these
      copper mirrors as ancient ‘selfies,’ not   The sages of the Mishnah debate   own time!             A member of
      for self-beautification, but to reflect   whether eating charoset on Seder night                   the Mizrachi
      with their spouses on their mutual   is a religious requirement or not.   Rabbanit Shani Taragin  is Educational   Speakers Bureau
      love for one another, hoping their   Supporting Rabbi Eliezer’s position   Director of Mizrachi and the Director of the   mizrachi.org/
      past beauty would arouse love in the   that it is a mitzvah to eat charoset, the   Mizrachi-TVA Lapidot Educators’ Program.  speakers


                                                                                                                   |  19
   14   15   16   17   18   19   20   21   22   23   24