Page 94 - EducationWorld May 2021
P. 94

Books




             Imperial perfidy            BAHAWALPUR: THE KINGDOM                       from which the ruler was
                                                                                       unable to extricate him-
                                         THAT VANISHED                                 self. “An agreement with
                    NABEL LOYD’S         Anabel Loyd                                   the Government of India
                    Bahawalpur is an     VINTAGE/ PENGUIN                              (in 1936), for its liquation
             Aaccount of the his-        Rs.959                                        in annual payments for the
             tory of this princely state   Pages 285                                   next fifty years until 1986,
             of the late colonial period,                                              became the sword over
             and its territories after ac-                                             the head of the ruler of
             cession to Pakistan when it                                               Bahawalpur,” writes Loyd.
             ceased to exist as a distinct   tutional status as a former   A history of the   Colonial officials ignored
             political entity. The pro-  princely state.       princely state of Ba-   the counsel of Bahawalpu-
             cesses whereby Bahawal-     By the time the British   hawalpur, its decline   ri officials, who considered
             pur was absorbed and     began penetrating this   under British rule and   the project ill-conceived,
             new, frequently altering,   region in the early 19th   extinction after the   especially as the water the
             administrative arrange-  century, the kingdom of   partition of India     river was capable of carry-
             ments were introduced    Bahawalpur extended                              ing was overestimated.
             for the governance of its   from the borders of                              Partition brought a
             territories are discussed   Jaisalmer and Bikaner   Khan V, from 1907 to   fresh set of problems. The
             together with the fate of   in the west, to the Sutlej   1947; the period of transi-  tragedy of Punjab was
             the erstwhile ruling family.   and Indus in the north. It   tion from the integration   replayed throughout the
                Loyd brings the story   was sandwiched between   of the state to its extinc-  province, though the scale
             down to the ongoing dis-  Ranjit Singh’s kingdom in   tion in 1955, and his death   and details varied. In the
             putes over the extensive   the north and Sind in the   in 1966.           case of Bahawalpur com-
             properties of the family.   west. In view of its strate-  Sadiq Muhammad was   munal violence and blood-
             Nevertheless, there is   gic location, in the early   an infant when he suc-  shed were definitely on a
             little reason to lament the   1830s the British sought   ceeded his father in 1907   scale much lower than that
             end of princely rule in   to enlist collaboration of   and was invested with full   in British Punjab.
             the state in the post-1947   the Bahawalpur court. The   powers of a princely ruler   Sadiq Muhammad
             period. Princely states in   diplomatic expertise at the   only in 1924. It may be   assured Mahatma Gan-
             the subcontinent existed   disposal of the East India   mentioned that the extent   dhi that the state would
             because British colonial-  Company was too much   of a ruler’s ‘full author-  extend full protection
             ism found them useful for   for the state’s ruling elites   ity’ was determined by   to Hindus, and “no-one
             stabilising and governing   and soon they signed   the Crown. Between 1907   would interfere with their
             the empire. They acquired   agreements which in the   and 1924 the state was   religion.” V.P. Menon not-
             their legitimacy from the   long run undermined the   administered by a council   ed that Bahawalpur was “a
             paramount power and in   authority of the court.   of regency under British   paradise compared to East
             turn legitimised imperial   The company would go   supervision.           Punjab,” an indication
             authority. The end of Brit-  on to use Bahawalpur as   Shortly before the ad-  of the contrast which the
             ish rule put an end to their   a base for its campaigns   ministration was handed   state presented to those
             relevance.               in the region when during   over to Sadiq Muhammad,   parts of Punjab which
                Loyd’s narrative is   the late 1830s and early   a heavy financial burden   the British had governed
             marked by a sense of loss,   1840s Sind, Baluchistan,   was imposed on Baha-  directly for a century.
             and perhaps even betrayal   Punjab and Afghanistan   walpur in the form of its   In 1955, the state was
             of the state and its ruling   became targets of its   share of expenditure for a   absorbed into the admin-
             family. This is reflected in   expansionist thrust. This   major irrigation scheme,   istrative unit designated
             the nostalgic reference to   strengthened the ties   the Sutlej Valley Project.   as West Pakistan under
             Bahawalpur as the ‘king-  between Bahawalpur and   Work on the project com-  the One-Unit scheme,
             dom that vanished’ in the   the British, and gave the   menced in 1922. To meet   and divided into three
             subtitle of the book. The   state considerable political   its financial commitments,   districts, formally marking
             travails of the state after   importance.         the state was obliged to   its extinction as a princely
             1947 were a product of      A substantial part of   take a massive loan from   state. The erstwhile ruler
             the political trajectory of   the book deals with the   the British India govern-  retained some privileges,
             Pakistan and not directly   several decades-long rule   ment, the repayment of   mostly of ceremonial
             the outcome of its consti-  of Sadiq Muhammad     which proved to be a trap   nature.

             94    EDUCATIONWORLD   MAY 2021
   89   90   91   92   93   94   95   96   97   98   99