Page 51 - EH65
P. 51

F ORUM                                                                            FORUM  |  EASTERN HORIZON     49







           energy into something more        including hatred is that they are   However, this is easier said than
           positive?                         to be ultimately eliminated, not   done and requires much training

                                             just weakened, in one’s quest for   and proficiency in the cultivation
           Ayasma Aggacitta: The Buddha      personal liberation from sufferings   of mettā. For instance, how many
           gave several options to deal with   or for full enlightenment to fully   people can abide by this exhortation
           anger, each of which can be used   serve others. In chapter 8 of his   of the Buddha (in Kakacūpama
           according to one’s disposition and   Fundamental Wisdom of the Middle   Sutta, MN 21) to a bhikkhu: to
           capability. I am not sure whether   Way, Nagarjuna says:            infuse with mettā, the bandits
           one can say that these options are                                  sawing his limbs apart?
           transformations from negative to   “Through elimination of karma and
           positive energy. Perhaps you can   afflictions there is liberation.  Fortunately, the Buddha gave more
           decide for yourself after you’ve                                    doable options elsewhere.
           read them in the next answer.     Karma and afflictions come
           Suppression seems to be a last    from [misconstrued] conceptual    Paṭhamaāghātapaṭivinaya Sutta
           resort as we shall see.           thoughts.                         (AN 5.161) mentions five ways of
                                             These come from mental            subduing anger towards a person:
           Ven Min Wei: The Buddha taught    fabrication.                      develop (1) mettā, (2) karuṇā,
           that hatred cannot be overcome    Fabrication ceases through        or (3) upekkhā towards him, (4)
           by hatred but by loving kindness   emptiness.”                      don’t remember or think about
           and compassion. In the same way,                                    him, (5) resolve on kamma as his
           darkness cannot be dispelled by   The question is how to bring about   own property, heir, etc. I interpret
           darkness but by brightness. So, we   that elimination and what are the   (3) as equanimity derived from
           have to face our anger and learn to   steps involved in achieving that   reflecting that his behaviour is a
           be aware of it, rather than suppress   capacity. One thing for sure is   product of present circumstances
           or avoid it. We are simply to observe   that suppression is not the best   and past conditioning which may
           our anger when it arises.         option, but at times that might   be beyond his control and (5) as
                                             be the only means available or    surrender by reflecting on the moral
           Our education system does not     known to the person in keeping the   consequences of his presumably
           really teach us how to cope with   afflictions from being outwardly   bad behaviour. One could also direct
           our emotions. Thus, anger is easily   expressed, in which case that is   the reflection on kamma inwards,
           misunderstood, especially in our   a welcome temporary solution.    e.g. I could have done something
           family and community, causing us   However, suppression is surely not   like this or even worse to her in a
           to suppress it and making ourselves   a sustainable method in dealing   past life for me to deserve this. Now
           unhappy, uneasy and off balance.   with kleśas. A better option is   I must repay my kammic debt wisely
           If we prematurely suppress anger   defusing the pent-up negative    and patiently without creating more
           because we think it is unworthy   energy or channelling it into     unwholesome kammic links with her
           to understand it, then we will fail   something neutral or, better still,   to be repaid again in future.
           to transform it. Science says that   into something positive. However,
           all emotions are natural, and that   this is easier said than done. One   Vitakkasaṇṭṭhāna Sutta gives 5
           emotions become destructive       must train in these methods on a   sequential methods, in the following
           only when they are expressed in   regular basis to gain familiarity and   order, of overcoming unwholesome
           an inappropriate way. Therapy is   gradually ease into it.          thoughts in general, including
           aimed more at changing the external                                 angry ones: (1) replace them with
           expression of the emotions than the   What are the common antidotes   wholesome ones (2) reflect on their
           internal experience of them.      for anger taught by the Buddha?   drawbacks (3) don’t remember or
                                                                               think about them (4) slow down
           Geshe Dadul: Across philosophical   Ayasma Aggacitta: The rule      those thought formations, and
           schools or practice vehicles (yānas)   of thumb is to apply what is   finally (5) forcefully suppress them.
           within Buddhism, the general stand   mentioned in Dhp 233: conquer
           on afflictive mental states (kleśa)   anger with non-anger or mettā.   Ven Min Wei: As the Buddha had
   46   47   48   49   50   51   52   53   54   55   56