Page 314 - INDONESIAN ISLAMIC CULTURE IN HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVES
P. 314

Mepsi (abbreviated from   intellectual thought which they had    to publish luxurious modern books                     belong to the older generations and    Nurcholish Madjid’s works next to those
                 Madjlis Ekonomi PSII/the   turned into the ideological basis for their   and important works on contemporary           are members of a group of people that   by other scholars like Syafii Anwar on
                 Economic Assembly of     activities and the guide in selecting the   Islamic thought written by young and              supported the Islamic cultural movement   new ways of Muslim intellectual thinking
                 the PSII) was a magazine   books they wanted to publish. Here, we   international Muslim thinkers in order             in the 1970s.                          and those of Bahtiar Effendi on the
                 published by Partai      will be specifically concerned with three   to offer a balance in the ideas on Islam                                                 relational patterns of Islam and the state
                 Sarekat Islam Indonesia.  Islamic publishers for they represent   (mizan literally means ‘balancing scales’).          Mizan’s most important effect in the   in Indonesian history.
                                                                                                                                        earlier stages of its development was
                                          —though not totally—Indonesian
                 Source: Perpustakaan                                             Mizam was presumed to be a Shi’i                      to publish the work of young Muslim    While Mizan continued its progress
                 Nasional (The National   Muslims’ sociological reality. They are   publishing house because of its                     intellectual thinkers from middle class   as a published of moderate books
                 Library of the Republic   Mizan, which represents moderate       publication of Dialog Sunnah-Syiah                    society who came to the forefront of   on Islam, another publisher came up
                 of Indonesia).           Muslims, Gema Insani Press (GIP)        and other works by Shi’i thinkers like                Islamic discourses and debates in      with a sociological basis in Tarbiyah.
                                          which represents scripturalist and                                       69                   Indonesia, like Nurcholish Madjid,     It was a group of Muslims who might
                                          fundamentalist Muslims, and LkiS        Ali Shariati and Murtadha Muthahari.                  Kuntowijoyo, and Amien Rais—people     be considered on belonging to the
                                                                                  However, Mizan occupied only a small
                                          (Lembaga Kajian Islam dan Sosial) that   space and it was surrounded by an                    whose fate had been fortunate under the   scripturalists and fundamentalists. This
                                          represents the Islamic left tendency and   Indonesian climate that generally ignored          New Order government. The government   publisher was Gema Insani Press (GIP),
                                          which is critical to both doctrines and the                                                   urged and supported them to do their   founded in Jakarta in 1986 by Umar
                                          social institutions they represent.     Shi’a. In fact, most books published by                                                      Basharahil. Under the motto “Penerbit
                                                                                  Mizan were books that belong to the                   doctoral studies abroad. In fact, they
                                          In the early 1980s, Indonesian society   Sunni branch of Islam and in the early               preferred Western universities to those of   Buku Andalan” (Publisher of Reliable
                                          was stunned by the founding of the      years of its establishment it published               the Middle East. Mizan issued a series of   Books), GIP mostly publishes translations
                                          Islamic publisher, Mizan and its two    books written by various popular al-                  publications named ‘Seri Cendekiawan   of books written in the Middle East on
                                          best-sellers Dialog Sunnah-Syiah by     Ikhwanul Muslimin figures, one of which               Muslim’, (‘Muslim Intellectuals Series’),   various Islamic themes such as Quranic
                                          A. Syafaruddin al-Musawi and Surat      is Surat-Menyurat Maryam Jamilah-                     which aimed at providing a platform for   commentaries, hadith, the history of the
                                          Menyurat Maryam Jamilah-Maududi.        Maududi. 70                                           newly growing ideas. 71                Prophet, Islamic theology, Islamic law
                                                                           68
                                          From the outset, Mizan, which was                                                                                                    and rituals, home and family, and Islamic
                                                                                                                                                                                      72
                                          founded in 1983, stood for something    Mizan targets university students as                  Mizan’s success generated other        politics.   These book were mainly the
                                          innovative. In fact, Mizan was established   its readership although most of them             publishers that adhered to similar ways   works of Ikhwanul Muslimin members and
                                                                                  have become the enemies of the new                    of Islamic thinking, but they did not lasted   supporters like Sayyid Qutb, Muhammad
                                          68.  Both books were written in 1983, when Haidar   ways of Islamic thinking about which      long. One of the most important was
                                          Bagir founded Mizan. Various observers had the                                                                                       Qutb, and Muhammad al-Ghazali. In
                                          impression that, initially, Mizan more represented   Mizan also publishes books including     Paramadina, the publishing section of   other words, GIP adopted a position at
                                          the development of Shi’i thought in Indonesia. This   the works written by Nurcholish Madjid.   the Paramadina Foundation. Paramadina   the opposite side of liberal Islamic thinking
                                          appeared, for instance, from the fact that 5 years
                                          after it founding, it published mostly works by Shi’a   The majority of the readers of Mizan   stood under the leadership of Nurcholish   and practices and it supports literal and
                                                                                                                                                                                                     73
                                          thinkers. From the 13 books it produced until 1988,   publications, according to Watson,      Madjid and, as might have been         puritan Islamic teachings.
                                          3 were written by Murthada Muthahari, and 1 by                                                assumed, Paramadina published most of
                                          Ali Syariati. See Watson, Islamic Books, page 185,   69.  Vermonte, “Penerbitan Islam”, 263.                                         72.  Halid and Zubair, “Peranan Penerbit”, 30.
                                          footnote14.                             70.  Watson, ”Islamic Books”, 184-185.                71.  Watson, “Islamic Books”, 185.     73.  Watson, “Islamic Books”, 196.


                 304  Indonesian Islamic Culture in Historical Perspectives                                                                                                                    Indonesian Islamic Culture in Historical Perspectives  305
   309   310   311   312   313   314   315   316   317   318   319