Page 267 - Chayei Adam LAYOUT sivan 5782

םדא הכוס יניד “ ו - מק ללכ ייח

ְּ
י ֵרֲה ֶ ׁש ,לי ֵעְּל ִד ְּכ יּוֹשָּע ֶה ן ִמ אל ְּו ה ֶשֲע ַּת םּו ּ ׁש ִמ ,הָּּכ ֻס ם ֵ ׁשְּל וי ָּ ׁש ְּכ ַע ךָּל ְּמִנ ֶ ׁש י ִּפ לַע ף ַא

ֹ
ּ
ּ
ְּ
ֹ
ה ֶשֲע ַמ תֹוֹשֲעַל ךי ִרָּצ ןֵכָּל ְּו ,תִיַּב אל ְּו אָּנ ָּמֲח ַר ר ַמ ָּא הָּּכ ֻס ְּד ,ה ָּרֹו ּת ַה ן ִמ לּוסָּ ּפ תִיַּב
ּ

ל ּטִּי ֶ ׁש ֹוא 124 , )כ"ע חכומ ןכו ב"ערו י"שריפ ןכ( ר ֶסֶנ ְּו ר ֶסֶנ לָּּכ ַעֵנ ְּעַנְּלּו םי ִר ְּמ ְּס ַּמ ַה לָּּכ רי ִסָּּי ֶ ׁש
ֹ
ְּ
ּ
ּ
ֹ
ּ
ב ַחר םי ִרָּסְּנ ַה ּו ּ ל ִפֲא ה ָּר ֵ ׁש ְּכ ּהָּּ לֻכ ְּו ֹומֹוק ְּמ ִב ר ֵ ׁשָּּכ ךָּכ ְּס ן ֵּתִי ְּו ד ָּח ֶא ר ֶסֶנ םי ִרָּסְּנ יֵנ ְּ ׁש ן ִמ
ְּ

ןי ִד ְּב י ִקָּּב ֶ ׁש ַחי ִכֹו ּמ ֶ ׁש ה ֶשֲע ַמ ה ֶשֹוע ֶ ׁש ןָּויֵּכ ,ה ָּר ְּק ִת ת ַרֵזְּּג הֶזָּּב ךָּּי ַ ׁש אלו ְּ 121 .הָּעָּּב ְּר ַא
ֹ
ּ
ּ

ּ
ֹ
ֹל
ּ
ּ
הָּי ָּה רָּב ְּכ ם ִא ְּד םי ִר ְּמֹוא ׁשֵי םָּנ ְּמ ָּא ְּו( תִיַּב ַה ת ַר ְּק ִת ת ַח ַּת ב ֵ ׁשֵי אּ ֶ ׁש ןי ִד ְּבּו יּוֹשָּע ֶה ן ִמ אל ְּו ה ֶשֲע ַּת
ְּ
ֶז
ּ
ר"אב םַג ְּו ןּוּי ִע ךי ִרָּצ ְּב ּ ה ַחיִנ ֵה א"מ ַה ְּו םִי ַתְּנֵּב ִמ ד ָּח ֶא לֹו ּטִל ֹוא קֵ ּפ ְּקַפֶלּו הָּביִזֲע ַּמ ַה לֹו ּטִל רי ִת ַהְּל ןי ֵא םי ִר ָּסְּנ ַה לַע הָּביִזֲע ַמ
ּ
126 ) : 31 @ 21 @ר ָּּת ֻמ ְּד ע ַמ ְּ ׁש ַמ
ּ

ּ
ּ
ּ
ּ
"םַּג" ןי ִמ ְּכ תֹונָּפ ְּד 'ב ה ָּשָּע ֶ ׁש ןֹוגכ ְּּ 127 ,הָּּכ ֻס ְּכ ֹוני ִד ,הָּּכ ֻּס ַה ן ִמ אֵצֹוּי ַה לַספ ְּּ ]חכ[
ְּ
ּ
ֹ
ֹ
הָּּכ ֻרֲא ָּה ןֶפּד דֶגֶנ ְּכ הֵּב ְּר ַה אֵצֹוי אּוה ךָּכ ְּּס ַה ְּו םי ִחָּפ ְּט 'ז ק ַר ֹו ּכ ְּר ָּא ד ָּח ֶא ןֶפד ְּו תֹו ּכ ֻרֲא
םדו רשב
sufficient since he will not confuse this with the roof was coated, removing the coating
sitting in his house, others (Levush, Bach חצ ) and undoing the nails is still not enough to
don’t make this distinction. While many render the succah kosher. The Magen Avraham
acharonim write that we should rule wonders why this should be, for after all,
stringently, the matter is largely academic scraping off the coating should be more of a
since, practically speaking, using any planks of proactive action than simply removing the
wood for s’chach is only permitted under nails which hold down the planks (Machatzis
extenuating circumstances anyway. Hashekel, Pri Megadim). Although he leaves
the halacha undecided, the Elya Rabba writes
126. Chayei Adam’s note: However, some that even the Ralbach only said that it is
say that if there was a tar coating on the insufficient to do so to every other plank (i.e.,
planks, we should not permit him to just the alternate option) but not if one scraped off
remove the tar coating and remove the the entire coating and removed the nails from
nails or every other plank. The Magen every plank. Accordingly, the Mishna Berura
Avraham remains undecided in this case, rules leniently.
and the Elya Rabba implies that it is
permitted. 127. A beraisa (Succah 19a) teaches that if’
Certainly the coating must be s’chach protrudes out of the succah, the area
removed since it is not valid for s’chach by under it has the status of the succah itself, and
Torah law. Even still, the Ralbach writes that if one may eat and sleep there. The gemara
267