Page 21 - EH56
P. 21

FACE TO FACE  |  EASTERN HORIZON     19








                    our moral evaluation of them, leading us to   kinds and just suddenly have the experience
                    judge them more harshly than we otherwise   of not-self; I envy them. But, I think, for most
                    would. So it stands to reason that if you have   people, it’s going to be more incremental than
                    a meditative practice that lets you start seeing   that. I think there can be a direct connection
                    things without such pervasive influence from   between the kind of practice that’s sometimes
                    feelings and emotions, you would start seeing   dismissed as merely therapeutic and the kind
                    things more clearly, because you’re escaping   that’s deeply spiritual and philosophical.
                    the fundamental mechanism of delusion.
                                                              How has having a meditation practice
                    While you are only interested in what     changed your own life?
                    you describe as the “naturalistic parts”
                    of Buddhism, you engage with Buddhist     Well, on the one hand, it has helped me deal
                    meditation in a way that goes beyond those   with anxiety and also with stress. At the end of
                    who see it mostly as a palliative technique   the day, if I’m feeling stressed out, I’ll sit down
                    or productivity tool. Meditation for you is a   and meditate for a while. But, at the same
                    way to pursue enlightenment or, at least, a   time, I have seen how doing that can lead to
                    way to become more enlightened.           something deeper, especially when on retreat.


                    Yes, that’s right. Although, I also wanted   While on retreat, I’ve occasionally had the
                    to draw a connection between those two    experience that the bounds of myself had
                    things. In other words, I wanted to convince   dissolved. As I described one experience
                    people that, even if their practice is basically   in Why Buddhism is True, I felt that a bird
                    therapeutic—they’re just using meditation for   singing outside the meditation hall was no
                    stress reduction or something—they may be   less a part of me than a tingling in my foot.
                    on the path to a deeper exploration that can   If you look at what paved the way for that
                    be enlightening. I think, for example, if you   experience, I think a big part of it is viewing
                    change the way you relate to your anxiety in   various things that I normally think of as part
                    such a way that you’re no longer identifying   of myself with less attachment. The interior
                    with it, then I think you could see that as an   of my mind was feeling more diffuse than
                    incremental realization of not-self.      usual, was feeling less aggregated than usual,
                                                              precisely because I was not closely identifying
                    In fact, this view is consistent with the spirit   with it. And I think that’s one reason there
                    of what the Buddha said in his Discourse on   seemed to be more continuity between what
                    Not-Self. He goes through the different parts   I normally think of as the interior of me and
                    of the mind and basically says: “Does it really   what I normally think of as the exterior. This
                    make sense to view this part of the mind as   made it harder to say where my “self” ended
                    part of yourself? You can’t control it. It leads   and the world out there began.
                    to affliction. Do yourself a favor and don’t
                    think of it as yourself.”  And yet, by the end of   I think this is morally significant, by the
                    the Discourse, he says: “And if you do this with   way. To the extent that you don’t see a big
                    everything you had previously considered   boundary between you and the world out
                    yourself, you will have achieved complete   there, you’re probably going to see less of a
                    liberation.”                              moral distinction between your welfare and
                                                              the welfare of beings out there. And, of course,
                    I think some people may be fortunate enough   this is part of Buddhist teaching: there can
                    to have spontaneous awakenings of various   be a connection between the experiential
   16   17   18   19   20   21   22   23   24   25   26